Discovery Dispute Over Settlement Communications and Work Product Protection
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertThe court addressed whether certain communications, relating to prior litigation and settlement negotiations, were protected from discovery as either work product or under the attorney-client privilege. The court reasoned that the attorney-client privilege did not apply because the communications were not made for the purpose of obtaining legal advice, but rather to relay factual information or proposals between parties. Regarding the work product doctrine, the court held that documents prepared in anticipation of litigation were protected, but that protection was waived for materials sought by the opposing party that directly contradicted representations made by counsel during settlement discussions, as fairness required the production of the contradictory material. The court also distinguished between materials prepared by the client and those prepared by the attorney, limiting the work product protection where the client's factual preparation itself became the subject of the dispute through reliance on it in negotiations.
Legislator-Regeste
AmtlichAUTORISATION DE CONSTRUIRE; PREAVIS; POUVOIR D'EXAMEN | Le DAEL a refusé à tort l'autorisation de construire demandée, car il s'est basé sur les préavis de la commission d'architecture et de la commission des monuments, de la nature et des sites qui ont méconnu le style de l'immeuble concerné, et qu'il a fondé sa décision sur une base légale erronée. | LCI.3 al.3; LCI.12 al.2 litt.c; LCI.89; LCI.93; LCUA.4 al.1
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertProvision cited for the imposition of court costs on the appellant.
Volltext
!
"#$! %% !"#$ %&"
"
& ' ( & ) *'
+**+* +* +*+*
'()'
*. /011201"*3/ $45&60 0/ 12 172 " 0 *8-9 /$0 " "&: : $0 0 ;<01 0=. "11 12 *851 (-51 05% " 1" !>' +?% "0 12 &0 1"1 0 1 /1@1 % /701 "@1 A0'5B C.
(. + 1 *88?% !"0 . >.% $0 1 > @ $ 5& A0'5B >C " 1 600 0& "0 0" " 0 0&4/1@1 "12/01121 0"%"0 0"/ 1 905A"083+9(C.
+. 00" (+ D0 *888% 6 4 > / "0 0" " 0 1" 06 7 "1100" /$0 A0'5B C "1100" 1"1 % 0 A0'5B !>C &0 &06&"27 :/0 & 0"& "0 % "0 0" E051 @0 0" / 0" "% 0 0 70 2 "0 . " %"D " 0 0 @""$ &/12. !>@1 6"1"2D 0"00 7"D 1 0 7 0"00/0 & 0""12.
F. +- D0 *888% > 0 D " " 00" 5 "1100" ""1 05" 0"A0'5B ! C 0&"7 "11 00 @06 7 !> 0 &21 /"" 4 0" E051 @0 "0 % '0 0 07/$0 :;<01 0=.
!> 0 @1 7060 4 " E 0&E "0 ;"12=% 0 " 0 0 0 @ "1 A 07051 @C 0& "12% "12 0 4 G $20 % " /5/0$ 6".
60% 0" 0"0 0 & 0" 0&1 1070 "$0 4$ 0 "H &0020.
3. +12*888% ! 66 " 702" 0 4/2""2D 0" 0&4" 0" 0".
9. 00"(36&0(---% ! D "1" 067 00" $0 E@06/E5"/2"&"0/0 0". 1 /&0 "20 4 010" 2D 0& " 0
)+,+)(--- '+)'
" 0" $0 1 " 10 /@0 /0 0" / 0 *( 0 ( "0 " 0" 0 0"0&*F&0*88?A0'5B I3-3C.
,. +&0(---%> !"0J.!." 6"1"5 02 100 06 " 00" ! (3 6&0 (--- " 00" (+ D0 *888 6 /1@ 1 "122K 01 0*3%/ $.
" "$ 001 4 ! /G 10D 5"0""&@ 0 07<01 0 "1 "12EE1" %00 7/&"0 112 !>%" &06 10 .
?. 10 (---% / 10 " D "> !.!. 4"601 0"00"(36&0(--- ! 00"6 1 (+D0*888%1" 067 /0 & 0" "0 %"0 0"E051@0 %0 " 66 0 "0 %/ 2 "7002 " 0 D00100241 0051 0@" 0".
8. (8 10 (---% 02 100 06 "" 0" "7G 0(910(---%0""&D7/4 60/ (--(.
*-. 0&1 *( *+"&12(--+% !.!." "00 0"%>: 070.
. (+D&0(--F%!.!."11"0"11 0"4 0 " 10 (---. !. !. 70 "1 0" " !. >.% /$0 "D % /0 0" !1 L #M0% $0 "0/ 00 /N&""&:.
*(. *? D0 (--F% 0 "1 0" " /7G 0."0 "0 0@0E 0 7 0" 0"/"& "0 1""@0 . " 6"0% 7"&00 6&"2000"&"D &":0 "& " " 1"0&002"0&002.
"&"7 7 1"0% !1 #M0 7 /0 & 0" "D 0 00 1002 1 "O 1"&1 $0 7 "5 /0112 0 0@0E &"00 "0 "11 1 :12"07 &":0 4 /01@ $ 1" @P "0 &0 " "& / 1 70 "0 5 0 . ""&:0'1G10 0 & 00112"
)+,+)(--- 'F)'
"& 1 0.0 & 0" 01"0/0 " 1G101 7"01120/"707.
!> 7 4 0 7 07 "1100" "0/01 1 &002%"11 "0 % " :" 0".
!.>.7 ""D 0 701 0&0020" @@1 "/0112 $ "0 7/0/" 0 @00105.1 0 /10" 0" 105 / 1 % " 11 & 0". "H % "0 417/0 & 0"%007/06.
"7 / 0 D10"" "" /0 0" 7% " " 66 ! % &0 E"7/1@&05" 0 0 0 4/0112.
60% !. >. E07 7 6G "" 0 "& @%1050 0". ""0 4" 0" &"0 "0 G 0/00 "0 100 E'
0&"0112/ 1G1"1./ 1" 0"4 " & "0 0"& .
0 1 0 01 0 E 0 60 7 "0/"&&0 !.>..
*+. 10&06&"2(8D0(--F/@0 &0 70 &"0 "& (51@0 "6"1$ 05&0". '
0 0 0 4 /0 0 122 4 /12 "0 " 0 0 "& @.
*F. "'"1100"$0 A0'5B> C !>"& 6"0&06&"2 *+D0 (--F%/"" 004 " 0 & 0" "0 1 0".
*3. *8" "2(--F%00"000& 112 02100 06.
/&" !.!.7/0/@00 /6600%10 "D : " *88,. !> &0 " &0 6&"2 4 " 0" 0"&/$0 >..>0 4%>&0/<20 &0 17@&/E 0"0 D" "D ."D 6Q 1"060"7%0 1 /"& E051@0 70 0 7 0"& :/0112%70"1" 0 D40 :1 %" 0E051@0 . !>""6
)+,+)(--- '3)'
004"D /&" " 0" 0".>0 4 &0% 6 / "0 0" " 0 00" 6H /"2D / "4 ! %1" 067/"2D 0"00 !>/ 0 6".
5 " *888% 10 " 0" 0". % ! 0 00""1" 0&6."&"D "1 6G 0 ;05=6Q ""%70 0 "& : "0 " 0 07 $$ 6"0"1 "& . 5 E1% !> "" 4 "& 6 00 "D %"7 0 G 41 "& "@0 " 6"1 $K 05 &0". J01 % /&" " 4 /100" "% 001 1" 06 7 ""0 0" !> 0 ""0 0" 00% " 00 0"0 /5% 00 "1 0 07<01 0/01120 0@0E.
10 7/0/@00 20/0 & 0" "12 / 0112 <01 0 " @ 0 ?8 % " / 0 8+ &"0 &0 !> . 7 E "1100" &0 &0 "" 6&"2 6 4 /0 10 (---. 0 7 !1 #M0 &0 70 1"0% " / E 0. " % 02 100 06 &0 "" 00 1 /"& E051@0 %107 0"/20 000" . D" "7%0 02100 06 0 "" "&"D %0&0 07"&"0 70&"00 7/&0 !> 70'0.
>7"0% @4D@.
*
*. D 1 0 & D00 0" "1 % " &2A .39 "0R"@0 0"D000(("&12*8F*' ' (-3P .9+.*0 ."0"100 0&*( 12 *8?3' ' 3*-C.
" "0 0"1 0 000"0 0@0 %6"4"0A .9-0 . C5070 0">.
(. >/@0 00" ! % 02 100 06 E " "&"0 /E1 & '0 "1" " 0 " " "1 $07 0607 A )3*)*88? + 6&0*88?C.@0 1G1"7 ! 0&0/"00""1100"
)+,+)(--- '9)'
&0%"11"1100" "1"1 % 0 A )3*)*88? 0 P )3?3)*889 *3 " "2 *889 G 0 P J. S < % "&"0 /E1 "&"0 00" 02 100 06% J(---3F+C.
% " D0 " % 02 100 06 "0502/E"""&"0/E1"7R0 "6" 4 &0 0&@ % R 7R0 " 0'1G1 4 1 /0 0"A )?8)(---?6&0(---P *8&0*8?8 T. D&0*8?8%007G 0 C.
/5% !>" 10&00&@ .>0 !> "D" &0 6&"2 /@0 1 /"& "@0 %/ . '0&0 /2""&0 @ 06%100 $@/"00""0 7/"0 1 "& (51@0 "6"1$ 05&0"%"11"" /$0 5/0 0""1 0""" 02. " " / D@0% 02100 06 / 01 66011 0@ "5'&2 10% /E$ 0&0 "0 05 6"0% 00 7 /0 0" 1"0. "H % 00"000%70"E 0/"0"/E01 "&6"0.
"1 "00" 0&@ "1100" 1 /0 0" 1 0"% 02 021 " "&"0/0 0" 660.
+. 7 "& 0 F 0 * "0 "1100" /201 /$0 (F 6&0 *89* A * 33C E "10"2" 0" !>%" 7 !> D"/$0 "1 " "H / 0 & 0" 2K 01 "0 " @ / 0 ?8 . 0 7/ 1"060 0" 05"0@1 " "0 / "$01 "10 "0.
& 00 "' " 0&0 "0% "& "0 R07 E 60 0 4 10 &0@ A.!% "0 100 06%".%(510 0"%%*88F%.*,?%U(.3.+.P.T %0 "0 100 06%F510 0"%K J6" '''!0%*88*%.9C. "& "0 E 0"1 &"0 66 " 06 7 0 " 0&0 & "0% 010 1% "0 4 0@0 $"7 % 1" 0&0 G 20 0 " 0 4 "0 70 A. !% ". 0 .% .*,8'*?- P . T % ". 0 .% .?C.
)+,+)(--- ',)'
% 1 05 1 / "0 0" " 0% D0 " 0 1 7% /2 0"0 0" @ E%/ "0 "07"1&0@D""O . /0 0" 0110 "& "0 00 D 060 0 G 20 " AG 02 6 *.+3F)(--( +* " "2 (--(% "0.3.(P J82*,,P )9-?)(--F3"Q (--FP (?)(--(*3 D&0(--(P.!%".0 .%.*,F'*,3P.T %".0 .%.?C.
/5%"& 0F0*"0"1100" /201 /$0 &0@*310(--F. %2 @6/ "0 0"0 0@0E1/ 08+ %4D"% 1"060 0" / " &0@. / "7"0 / 0"0 0"70/07/ @0 0"/@0 &0 "1100".
" 7% " E %&0 !> 0 " 1 052K 01 412" @ / .?8 .V""% 02"2&7/ 0 8+ 0* &"0 71/ "0 0"%007 &E 6 0"6W "0 " 0112&04/ 0?8" "10 E &0 "1100" /$0 "1100" 1"1 % 0 % " 6"0 0 " /"00"/"1100".
F. V "% "0 " 0 0@0E 7 0" /1 " " 1 /"& E051 @0 "0 /0112". ! 66 " 1":$" "@$0 /0112 / " 7 0"/ 0" " " 0 0 4 0@ " 0" /0112 7 1"060 0" "0 0 &002 . " % 4 /0 " % &0 "4"2D 0"D 0".
5"%0 024""001G1 1 /"& E051@0 %&0"&"0/E1.
3. 2K 01 0 0@0E "10 E 0 ?8 . " 0" /0 $0 20 07& 0/ " 0" 2"A6. )(39)*889,10*889%"0.+C./ 08-0*&"0 00 7 12 " /0 $0 20 07 "15 " 10 7/ "& 0" 6"1 0"% " % 1G1 7 1 0051 0@ " 0" "0& 5@ @ G &@. &"0 " /0 0"/ 0*( .
)+,+)(--- '?)'
>/@0 00" " % ! / 2 / 0 *( 0( ""H "&"0/0 0"010 E5"2"&"0/0 0".%/ 0*(0(/ 02/5%0" /0 0"7"12/0112 0 0@0E 0" / 0 $ 6" 0 5 " /0 0""@ 0"&/ 0*(0(. 00%/ 08- 4 " "0 " " 1 /"& " @0 "0 7 0".
"&0 " 10 0 / 4 " " 4 0" 7 ! " 01%2&0 !> 700 A6. . + . + P )(39)*889 , 10 *889C% 7 1 /"& E051@0 " &00 4/ 08-0* .
9. "10 0" "0 "0 0" 1 " 0 07"" $0 0 ;<01 0=.""&:0'
1G1 0 "0 "1" "& E051 @0 4 1G1"77" 0"2K 01 0 0@0E.!00 E'
0& /0112 " " E1. " % E 0112 /12% E " *F *9 2"& $% " D4 "& /01" "& 6"1 0& 70 / E 0&E "0 .
/ "7"0012"%"0 &/$0 "0/$0 /&" 0" :%/""600 4/1@1 "12 /0112 7 0"% 7/4 0" (51 @0 % " 7'0"0 010"1" 6"1"0.
%" 2046007" 0& !> . "0 '1G11" 0& 0"&0@ 06. 00% !>10"/0"1 0"7 07 "1100" "0 /01 1 &002% "11 "0 % " : " 0". 1 0 07 "1 02 & / 0 8+ 0 ( % 70 0 7 "1100"6"1 &05/G 0@&0 0"0 0" 70 " @0 /1@1 00 0 7 0% " 0"XX5105 2 XX5105. "07/0"0 % 7 0" & " &"00600 0 6" @1 0 @ 00/0112".
>" !>% : /0 & 0" "D 1 0 7 0" 00/0 & 0""12 12*8 (-5105% 6 07" '1G17 % " 0 0 4 @@& . 65@1 4" 0""12 "1" 0&"&0@ 06." " 6"0/0 0"7%/@0
)+,+)(--- '8)'
/01127 0"%0/@0 ;"12=%10"12. " % "12 "6600 2 " 4 60 "0 " : "@1 . 5 "% /@1 !> 7 E "12 &5 6"1 7/0 1"H 0E051 @ /01120 0@0E.
,. 7 0""&"00/" 0& !>"7/" 0 7 ; 0" E051 @0 0 " 66 0 "0 % / 2 " 7002% " 0 D0 0100241 0051 0@" 0"=.
/0 0" 5@ /$0 07 4 6"1 0" "0 :;<01 0= " 1 0"0.> "0/01" 7 6"1 /01" 7 7 0 1 "0 : ; =% 0 "&0 0 "1 "1 0200 & "0 & 1@ 0& 7 " "% % "$$10% .
00% D" 1 Y " 7 0 010" 0 4 " & Y 7 105% / 0 /0@/ 1 4"12"& 0". "0 "0 /01127 0"77"& 602010" "0 D" 0 0 "& 0" 0 4 0 4 "1"0 0" /12. / " "02 0& !> 70 " 0 "0 0" " 2" " 6 00 H 0"" 0"/5.
/&5007"D 1 /"& "@0 "0 /01120U*3/ $/66 010 0 /0 $0 /12 " @ / 0 8- . "0 % 7/1 0051 0@ " 0" & 1G1 0% &@% "11 "& "12 $$ "1 0" "0 " . 60% / " 1 4/0 " 6% 7 "0 E1 " " "0 0" " 0 1 05 /$0 % 70 0 1 " 0 05 "0 " " "@ ". % 6 / "0 0" 0 1 6"% 7/020 &07000 A .+.+ C 701"00 :/124" @%"1G17/0 & 0" "D " &00 0 10 0 /0 $0 /01120 0@0EE0@"0A .8-.* C.
?. /0 0 0@% 1"1 W. 010 " / 1" <J +R---.' " " 4 $@ / . ZZZZZ
)+,+)(--- '*-)'
+ *(
,-./ 0!1
&2 " 0 D + &0 (--- !"0 J. !. " 00" "1100" " " 1 05 " 0" (3 6&0(---P
./"1
/1 P
00""1100" ""1 05" 0" 0 1 /1@1 %/701 "@1 (+D0*888P
"" 1 /1@1 %/701 "@1 0& / "0 0"1P
0 7/0/ W/1"1 P
"" 010 <J+R---.'4$@/ P
"1107 G 4 ! " #$ % &" " 00 7R 1 R1@1 % R701 "@1 4 "1100" ""1 05" 0".
>0@ B!1"&:%0 %!.:$5%!1<0%!. $0%!1"%D@.
"1 02 100 06B
@6605'D0 B &0'0 B .0"'>0@0 ."&:
)+,+)(--- ')'
"0"6"1 G "1107E 0.
5&% @6605B
)+,+)(---