Contractual Supersedure Dispute
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertA dispute arose concerning whether a particular contract, signed by the parties, applied to a subsequent related transaction or whether the subsequent transaction was governed by a different, previously established, contractual framework. The court reasoned that the language of the later signed agreement clearly evidenced the parties' intent to supersede or replace the prior understanding regarding the subject matter of the second transaction, finding that the later document was an integrated agreement covering the scope of their dealings, thus upholding the terms of the second contract.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generiertArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Supersedure Dispute: The court reasoned that the language of the later signed agreement clearly evidenced the parties' intent to supersede or replace the prior understanding regarding the subject matter of the second transaction, finding that the later document was an integrated agreement covering the scope of their dealings, thus upholding the terms of the second contract.
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertImposed costs upon the appellant.
Volltext
!! !"#$%&'(&)$*
*
"# # " # $$$"#$ %$& '(
# "$" # $
"+,-"
$
12 344444%2 25("678' *( ** 9)* (68 *$ : ;44444 : 6$) * < ) * =; ( 8( *''* ) ($( (:8 (*)>*' (* (* * &'() >*' (* ) '8' *( = () *&(8 (( ? ' * < '*(2 8' (( (* = *( ;@ ($( '<<2
'*( *'< * *'( : =('A : * 5("
67%921B$(C1'<+..1)*( ( '*D ;"( ( =%2 >*( ( *''((* (*CE$='(( (*>( *5("
67='(( (**= F 9:='*D)'* G:= F ( : HFC1-=-+I)/I*(*1B$(C1'<+..12
+2 =('A *( J $='*D:='(( (*(;B* ?(($ >('*(2)*( = ( ?( $' B$(:'+..1)(**?= F (C'(+..1) =&)(B*(8 8(( (*&( B*2
C2 I$(+..+)*( ( :='(( (**** (' * '*( =*G : '< +..1 (( ? * B$() >$( +..+) * ( HF 1K/=/K+)I. * **( =?( (' ' HF1.=...2"2
L2 1K$(+..+)= F > **( (*)'* (>(>( ? *'' ( =* B:$('*D2
I2 +0 $( +..+) *( ( : ( ' >( 5("6 7 ' 9 * *$ 8' (' (>>*:$(: (* >( 2 $( '<* >(;:? *6$5("67 9?($( > ( * 8' (* (8 ( 2 $( 8' *68' 8*() = %)) 2 = ( ?( $&=%G*'*(B$(+..+2
02 1I'(+..+)( ' *:*( (? ( (' * = +..1) * G HF 1CL=1/+)C. $ J $:(* HF1+=...2"'*(C.B(+..+C1'( +..C2 >(( (' = ( *?(('A * +..+ ( ?( ' 2
,+.-/,+..0 "C,-"
/2 *'' :*( C.'(+..+2 "( >> (?$' HF1+=...2"CB( +..+2
K2 *( +K B$( +..C) ' ( *( (>*' ='(( (*?344444%2 2>(( =*<B =*B*' >(( $ (< '(6 ( 2 * &8 * +..+$( 8)D*'(=%2 *' ($() *( **( $) ( =%+..1) HF1KK=0C12"2
-2 C >$( +..C) = F > **( (*) ( ' D * (? ( (' * +..1 ?=* * *( 1I '( +..+2 $( =8( ' * '(( *<2
1.2 1+>$(+..C)*( = *$>*(:( ' * *(( 8' ) 8 ( (* (>>(( ? *$( 2
112 *(+I>$(+..C)( ' * ('(C.$(+..C *D* HF1++=1/+)C.) (*=( J '* *(' $2
1+2 *'' +/ '( +..C >( > : '( 'C.'(+..+)( (* (*:*( ' HF1=...2")D<C.B*)>*= (+I*( =('*( (*:**&D(? '*+C '< 1--L5%"C+.92
1C2 0 B( +..C) 344444 %2 2 $ ' (*2 ( * =B*' >(( 2 ) =% ( ( B*' )(**?='M*( (<M $( J 2* (*:='(<$( J *$2
1L2 % ' (* * ( (() ='(( (* (8(>(:*( *$' HF1=...2"1-*G +..C) > C. '( +..+ ( B*(8 $ (; B* *'' HF1CI=-0+)+ID*'(( J 2
1I2 +. *G +..C) *( ) $ ' (* * * '2
102 1/ '< +..C) ='(( (* '( =' 1- *G +..C)* (>(*>*'' := (+I%2
= '('(6' (* ($:=' HF1=...2" * (>( +/ '( +..C2 * '* ($ (* ((*
,+.-/,+..0 "L,-"
' (* 1/ '< +..C (( >( ? =' $( * (>(*>*'' := (+I %)??* ( ( B (>(>( ?*''=$( D'8 ( ?( *=$( 2!8=B*' >(( )= ( ( *B* ($ &8*($( ((J D2
1/2 + * *< +..C) = F (8 *'' (* : 344444 %2 2 ( B*(8 D HF 1C/=/CC2") *( * ( G *+..1 ( J 2
1K2 -* *<+..C)*( *6*''((* * *' (6=('A 5("67*''((*9* ((* ' (* 1/ '< +..C ;* < ?= ( =('*(<(( 8=?( 2
1-2 344444 %2 2 ( $ 6 ='(( (* 1- *$'< +..C2 *( <( *$(*( <( C1 *G +..C2 ( =*< ( = '(6 ; "** ( = (' ((; ()* = F )** '=((' 2
+.2 +0*$'<+..C)='(( (*> * <* (* (( =%2 $( *$>*(*( *344444%2 *82
+12 B8' 1I '< +..C) (< '(6 ( 6$*:*( (*$(*(*;'*() ?*( *( J ;* *( 2 *''(((*$(*( *''2
++2 +0 ' +..L) ='(( (* * B *2 $( B: > * <* +0 *$'< +..C2 : =' (>(8:*( 1-*G +..C**"(' =%+..1) ( * :>( >*2
( (*= (+I%)**( '* ';('' ?( *$( J (>(8 *? * (<<) '8 *'' (*) '?( ( (*' *8(8:*<(8 (*((*'< $ 8( (*=%2= (+I%**( * *( := (II *(>N&'*( (*('A ( * *'' 1L'<1--.5H"%0L+21L92=% ('*D $( J $(;B*($ =& (*('*< 344444 %2 2 =$( & ' +..12 <B ($' )=(> (* ( 8$2*( $( 8"$ *''('* $( (**?=($( 2 +..L)( (**=%+..1= ( *B*8(2*( $(
,+.-/,+..0 "I,-"
>(( : *<(8 (* +..1 ?= +..+2 =8' (' *1I'(+..+=$( $ 8 2
; 8' (> ' : =B*' >(( )( ( ($ 2
+C2 +C'(+..L)*( (?2
(<'(6( $( *''*''((( () * (' =$( >> ? * *2 *( ( ((=('*(<(( B((?=?( ;' "
($( J ' ('' 2
+L2 = F '<$*( ($( :(?2
+I2 $&) *''((* *(( *( ) *$'< '< +..I) * (* ((* ( >(( * * *' *: <(?=(( ( ( ( $*=%G* +..12
*( I '< +..I) *''(( ( ( : =( (* *''((* ? 6 ? ( $( * *D) *''((*$( =?( ?(;( ( '*' ( ( ?(>(( (' =*<B *** ():'*( = ( ' (( (* ($(68 8;2 $&) *''(( $( $( (' *$ * )?=($( >( 2
%() ='(( (* <>((( ($(68 8; >(( * ( ' ** (2 ** D &*'**8)($( >**<(8 *(* *()D*'(*; ?( =D $( &) $' ($( $( * >> = (*= F ($:=%2(' ) *** ()=>( ('** ( <>(( = ($(68 8 $(( : ($(8( ( (' 2 (' ( **( *( =$( *( )>*((*< )D=(G:=%?(>(( =*<B =** (2
+02 ((* K '( +..0) *''((* B * '( '*' HF L..2" : &8 344444 %2 2 *( ? ( (8 * ( ? (* $*( ( =' HF 1=...2") (>(8 : *( = F * (( ) ( >* * (( ?* ( 2 *(?344444%2 2=$( <(?=(( ( ( ( $**G=%+..1)=$( *( *' *>>(( <( ( ( (*2 *( $( 8(
,+.-/,+..0 "0,-"
8(82 >( 8' ( *' >( ?= =$( *B* 8( ( (* $(":"$( >(2 ?* ( =' (>(8 ( '* 8 > *''( ( (* >((6 * 2()(( ( '((*( $( *''( *' =%) (> (*$= (+/% *' *( 2
+/2 * KB(+..0)344444%2 2** ((* 6 (<'(( (>* :'(: ;( (*2 *(( ( : ( <=( (* 344444%2 2
+K2 11 B( ) = F * B * ;( (*2 =' $( * < (* $(* (* = *<(8 (**=+..12
+-2 +1 '<+..0)B88 (*' (* * =?J **:=( (* *( 2
2 ='(( (* * ((? ?= (8*( * ? (* "( =$( ' (* * =' **+/'(+..C2'('>( C.'(+..+$( )* )8' *='**1- *G +..C (=D$( = *'' (*2 ' (* * '"( $( B 1/ '<+..C2 * (*)*( ( B*' >(( >*' ='(( >( ?==$( D =%+..1(?(($( >(;2
<2 ) ( ;* ?=( $( *'' B8' (< '(6 ( + *G +..+2 $( * ( '(()* '' +C'<+..+ +1'(+..C2$( 8 : B8' =B*' )*( +*G +..+)( B*' D **8 B?= *$'< +..C2 = ( & : D * 2 $( *(( *( = <(' = $( < =((' 2= >:** +1'(+..C?( ( ' (* ? ='(( (* =% $( > = '<*' 2$( (*($( '**'(($( ?(=%=$( D2 >( =8( (2%( ((' $( >> >$= %) ;')'8((=8( ()= ( (?' * ' $(*( 2
C.2 B88*?(* (*B8' =B*' >(( +CB$(+..C?(( +0 '<+..0 8:B82
,+.-/,+..0 "/,-"
$ #
12 B ' ( $ B(( (* *' ) * $<5 2I0 *(N*8( (*B(((++*$'<1-L1" " + .IO 2 0C 2 1 2 *( * '(( ($ 1+ '<1-KI" " I1.O 2IC21 IL*(*>( L* *<+..1"F("C1/92
+2 *(*? ='(( (*=* '=((?*=(*' (**)= F = ' (** ( * ((( :* (>( (*: *( * '(6'+/'(+..C2((* ? * * ? ((* ' (* ( 1/ '< +..C * ='1-*G +..C2
C2 = ( +I %) M( ?() '8 *'' (*) '? ( (*' * 8(8 : *<(8 (* ?( ( (*'< ( = ' HF 1=...2" O 8$ * (($) =' HF1.=...2"M2
: = ( +/ %) ( $*( ? M( ?() $*( =%) * : * *>( * ( = ( '* @) ( ='(*' ='B?=: HFC.N...2"2 (<*( *' M2
L2 ( ? ='(( (* *( $ : ( ( *( * *( * 8) *( (* = B'( >> 2
I2 *$( * '( ( =' ;( : 344444 %2 2 1-*G +..C = *>*'' ; 68 * * (") = ) & )( >**(((*>( ?=: 1- *G +..C) *( ( <>( = B*' >(( )? $( **8B8' (<'(6( C B( +..C B?= C. *$'< +..C) *>(' >* (*2
02 <( ** ?344444%2 2= = ('( ?( ( $( * *D ( ' 1I '( +..+ =?( $' ') C.B(+..+ C1'(+..C) * G * =% +..12 <( 8' ? +0 *$'< +..C) = F > * <*2
>( ) * =;*( ** = ' * $(* (**<(8 (*= (+I%2
,+.-/,+..0 "K,-"
/2 ) =' * (>( 1- *G +..C = = *'' (* *'' ?(6 * = ( +I % * $ ='(( (*2 >> ) ( =' +/ '( +..C <( = *'' $ *'' (* C. '( +..+) '( '( $*(*'' (**='1-*G +..C2
K2 *'* (>)='1-*G +..C= * (>(8(6' = (+I% *''((*( G=2
-2 *?)*'(*'* (>2((* *''((*)'J'?((*' (*(='(( (* 1/ '<+..C)* 2
1.2 (* =6)( @='*' ( *=('( * *< ( 8('(*(* ?==*$5 2K/ 92
$&) '*' HF 1=...2" '( : &8 ='(( (*>( *5 2K/ 92 PPPPP
'"$# $
)*+,-.
$<*( B KB(+..0344444%2 2* ((* *''((* **' (6N('A K'(+..0O
+,-/.
=' O
((**''((**' (6=('A K'(+..0 ' (* ( ='(( (* >( * 1/ '< +..C((?='1-*G +..CO
( ?=(= *=('( O
' :&8='(( (*>( *'*' HF1=...2"O
*''(? J :!"#$%&'(&)$* * ): *''((* * * ' (6 N('A (( ?=: N'(( (* >( *2
,+.-/,+..0 "-,-"
%(8 7 !'*$D)( )!2D&6)!'H()!2 &()!'*) B82
*' (<'(( (>7
8>>(6"B( B7 $("( 7 !2 **( 2*$D
*(*>*' J *''(?; (2
6$) 8>>(67
,+.-/,+..0