Covenant Enforcement Barred by Abandonment and Changed Circumstances
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertThe dispute involved a party's right to enforce certain covenants related to property use, where the lower court found that the restriction was abandoned or waived due to a pattern of non-enforcement and changed circumstances, specifically concerning the erection of structures deemed violative of the original intent. The reviewing court affirmed, reasoning that the long-standing acquiescence to uses inconsistent with the restrictive purpose, coupled with significant changes in the character of the neighborhood, demonstrated a clear abandonment of the covenant's enforceability, justifying the trial court's determination that equitable relief was unwarranted.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generiertArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Covenant Enforcement Barred by Abandonment and Changed Circumstances: The reviewing court affirmed, reasoning that the long-standing acquiescence to uses inconsistent with the restrictive purpose, coupled with significant changes in the character of the neighborhood, demonstrated a clear abandonment of the covenant's enforceability, justifying the trial court's determination that equitable relief was unwarranted.
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertThe costs of the proceedings are imposed on the appellants.
Volltext
!
""#!"!$!%&$ '( ') * '( ') + ' !"!#$%$"
"
,- '' ' . .' ' ' /..( ' ' 0 . .
&'())&
'
)- !. #/. " ". ". "0 " .1#/.2 .3.&456 7%.4#8 "#%" 9. )'%" : ;<". .";0..- &..";=11. " . "0. ',' >?% @ :A "< :". " .$. -
'- - ''0.'+++%$. ";" "<""#."8" B =11.@ ."- "."%." @ . ". 0""<9:". ":.0. # 1.<C""" ."C.),0:)DEF3.&6 E)G-*)E-)G'7-
:- )G 0: '+++% $. . .$. 0 " ." =""#.C.1"0 ."3.&45. .$.71.< 8 6 . = 'E1$.'++)"< $<0. "1"0. ""1".=.4-
*- )F 0. '++)% $. " " ." C. 3.&45 $.7" @0".1. ."" 8C. ."11.. 8 # . "0 " C. 8 "# 0- 1". $. 1."11".". .1C.0 ."$.C =.04%" . C# . C.-
G- $".. 9 " . % . .$. 1.< 8 6 . = )F H$. '++' " 0 ;. ." < "0% " 0 C0" -606 )EH$.'++'%. . " *+ 0:0I0-
F- 6. 8 . $"..#% $. C )+ H. '++*- ":$ C0.." 10 ".- " .# 8 . .$.".))H. '++*-.0."1"0. 8C.$. I 1.<-
,- '*"A '++*"$00.."" 11 - " @ . ". 0""<9 :" 11 #/<. $.0. ; - . ".C$. 11 8,%*E* )*J0#(0*%"@.0. . 1.<8)F+ 0#(0*- 0""<9 :"% 0 11.=. < J)'*% F+)) ),)*0#(0*"$.0. E++0#(0*-
J- ''" ":'++*%"C$$.%!!-#/." ##81.#C. .""" -
('*))('++, &*())&
E- 'EH.'++G%. 8"$. %$.C .< " 8 "$ C0.." 10 ".- 0. " 8 . .$.-
D- D 0: '++G% !!- #/. " "1.0 $. @ ##$. 11 . 8."''" ":'++*-. %. " 1". " C. % ..@ ". . $ ." C '++G- "$@."$. I $. "9 @".4 :".$. I ..".0 =.44)+H$.'++F-
)+- 'E $. '++F% "$ 0 " 11 $.- $ . *J+%'J)%*)) 'FJ0#(0*" .". DDJ,%FD*+%F'J' GD*F0#(0*"0""<9:"-
))- '+0.'++F%. .$.1.<86 .*+H.'++F" 0 ;. ." "1"0. "% = % "" .# C..0 -
6 ;"-"$.= *)H. '++F. .0 ."180; ". %". ."-
)'- ' 0:'++F%!!-#/." 1. $.8. .$. ".C".C. 6=0.6- -..@ @C."$. "" .##.0".1. ." 9C. ."-6C#. 00 =.4%.". ; 8 $.$ . 0'++,-
)*- .."'G0.'++,%. .$.1.<."C..& 0 C. ." *+ 0: '++, . ." . E )+ .-
)G- '*H.'++,%6 "4 .:0.. .1" .." . .#. " 8 " ." % :...0 % 8 1.< ." C.C..0 .@%$. 1. -
0.. <. . 8 "# . 4 C .4 0"9. $.# & .@"8 0"0 - :A. "<:".=11. $ =0.- = % @ . ".4% <0% C . :A-$ ."#. "A .0" -
C. ." . $. . - $. #.40 1. .0. .- =11. 1" .". 0% 0. .@0 . H" % J=++ 8 )'=++ )*=++ 8 ),=*+- "": % $".. C . . CI ."00"10-
('*))('++, &G())&
..%6 ":". $ ". "" . 0<.00 0.." 10- ; 0 " @; 1.#. "0 C.% " ".# @ " "$". % $. " 00 . # 9 40 "0: ."-%.1.<. .$. . .11. " C" ." C$. < I00 "A % ". $." KL )J'C+++-&% " "0. 1. C -
1. C . " :- 0.. . " . 0 " " % @. . "@ ". " $.# & .@0"9-%". ."11 $<$. C" H8..@@;". . $.$ H$.'++J-
" ." .$ . 0 $.#5 . 8 ;:" ." ; ". @ . .04 ". !!-#/. 4% 6 $.#. 0# 4 " ." .00:% ". .@ $."- 0 .#0 $. H8 "4$."0 -
"0 0 %..". .#. . .. "" .". M."$. 1.<..@%@.0 . 8 0.. $.$- % 0. "1"0. . ."" ."% $ ;.$ .0 1... 1" ."0 .".@=.4-
". 1 $"9. . ".. C..0 .@ @. "$. I . .$ . ".1"..8$1.<" .0. $ .$ 0.."- ;4% $ ; . ". 1". .%;#. .". "0""<9:"%.1. . "0 1" ."0 .".@ =11.- ". 1 $"9. #0 #0 " C . ." "@C ..0 . ."" ."%" 00 . =.@"C<". ." 0 . "C.C . " :""0.@0 -
)F- )JH. '++,%. .$."":$ ."- " H "-
..". $. . 8"#"% @;. & ."@ ."C$. H0. "1"0 <$.0. - 0 . .$0 .0" % ":.0. " . ". .<1"..0. "0""<9:"-
."..C..0 . .@-0.4. $ ." . .$. $. . )G 0: '+++- 6 $. H8 :1.. . #% 0. 0# . .$ ##% C. ." C$. "H"I ..-
('*))('++, &F())&
6C#. C" ".C"$..@%". . " .< % ". ." . @ 0.." ". .1. 8 1". 0. $ .0. - ". ." C . 0.1 0 0.- "H 0 C . C . # . 11. CI C. ."..@-
"0 C.0" 0 $.0. C0.& ."% . C9 $. 0 .$ 8 C..0 - :.0 <.# . .. 1. @ " C. % . C . ".: C$.#"$<##"0".1. ."-
C#0 6 % 1" 1" ."0 ".@ C. ."% C . . .@ C. 1.. 1 8 C .. ." . ."% 1 " 1" ." 0". =-
),- . " "0 ." " )) 0: '++,-
- !!- #/. " <" @C 0= $ 0.. C$. .- $=% " $. 8 $". . $. 0- 0#0 . . : $ .1. ."C=:. @ .-
C$ .""<"A . KL'C+++-&0". ." . %. 9 . $& &$. 4 .0" 0."- 0 C . $.#:-
6 $. :".;..@"0 "1"0. $ "0- " .. 1. @ . .$. $. < .."=.4$.%"N.$. 1.<8.@ -
" 0 . "0 . .<-
:- . .$."1.0@C.."1"0C$. .$ 1. C":H "- ; ". $. 4 "% 6 $. . 0= " 0. < ":40- 4 C"0 ..@%.."1"0$. -
- .:.0 .8. .$..= *+ 0:'++, " 0.<. @. .@ . "8". .$."0."1"0. =.4-
('*))('++, &,())&
)J- '' 0: '++'% . .$. ..@ @ < . ." 0 ."6 "C.1" .". 8C=.<  " :".-C9$. C0.." .".$ 9"0: .:-
0.C=.4. '+%$L"I %$ 0.." " 0""<9 :" . .0. ".- $=%"11 #/< . -C. ."". < <.# .$8C=9#.4C.%0. .1.. 8" ""0. C#.- . ."% C. 0 . 1.< . "$ H@C8.<"11 C..0 @.- .% " B . 0". 11 % 1. C @C. C9 $. H" .". ."-.1.<.." . =. -
<.40 % . ;#.. C =.4 . DG% " L". % "N @ ." " ." C. $. I " 4 ##- 6 :. . ":40 0 "0 " C""0.C#.-.1.<.." . .=. -
<"$. I "08.6 %@. . .<":40" ."-
)E- )," ":'++,%6 ; $" .. ." "9 $C..0 =.4%". @ 0".@.". .<"". .$.. %0" .1@"%.9 $. ":40" ."-. .$.$. .@C .)+. ".%" @;"0."$. I ".:-
" 0 . .: "0 @ . .$. . . .A0 : 0..0.. .11. "4 @ . C":.# ."0. #0 ". ."-
)D- 6@".% ." .1"0@C11. . #8H#-
' .
)- H 0 . $ H.. ." "0 % " $:3 -*+-)4#0 " ."C.&O)J+-+EM -F, ".C"#. ."H...''"$0:)DG)&& '+FM -,* -). -"."0.. .$)' 0:)DEF& & F)+7-
'- @;. # .; .'D.' " . ."1 "1 ." . )E $. )DDD 3 -& 6 )+)7% ". ;I "0" 00 ". ";. ;"11.$ . %
('*))('++, &J())&
". ".% ;": . @;. ". " . 8 "11 $ . % ..8;0.. ."$ ."8 " 0".;<.0" %"@ 8.1 .." 8 - ". 1. 0.. $ C0I= H#"8C0.. ." .$"11 " 8 . ." .. .4% .. C. @. . @&.". C080".1."".."" . 1. 8 :. H8 " ." " ". 3 I .: 1 '-'++('++* J " ": '++*% ".- *-)M '-JJ('++* D H. '++* ".- '-) I . M ()J'('++G ' 0 '++G M (*D('++G)*H$.'++G".-'7-
C4% .: ".4 @;. ." ;0 11. """ . .#-;9...;"" 0;. .""00 . "."" 8 " H -
*- - C. " : " # C="00% .0< % :." " :.""% .. @ "% " ." 0"=.@ ..: " ."00" #. .0. ." $ .$ 0.." < . ." @. " ." 3 - ) .7- " < *% " 1.< $ .0. C0.." " . ." "0: ." .0 :".3=.11F''<*.7-
C ". $. 8@. ." .".<. @. "" < <.# C"" ". ..- 1.< .C..0 .0":". ."C .$. 3 -E-) '.7-
:- 4#0 "" ."C.)DH.'++'3O)J+-+EM.& 454#0 7.":.# ." . 0 C. ." #. ."10 .4" ."C. .# ". "C< ."3 -)4#0 7-
6C#. $ .0. C0.."- 4#0 $". 8 1.<C.3 -,-'4#0 7 C< ."0. ..@C..0 " 1. "1"0. C.3 -E-F -D 4#0 7-
C. ." "1 . %". ".%$. . .$.% =#" B.0. ."$ .$0.." C..0 . ." .". C . ".1.@ .1.8D++>?3 -)+-G -4#0 7-
('*))('++, &E())&
G- 6 .0 @ .." " . .. "" .". % C ." . @ 0". $ " C< ."C..0 C:C .$$.#-C % . 00 C. ." . ""0.@0 " : P. 10 6 -
- .."" .". .0.@@0"9="..". " 8 .: 1.< " C . 0".#$<. I .$%"0 "0 ". $ C. I :. 3 L )'* ))' ".-G-)') I . 7-
:- 00 . <. % . .0" % 8 . $ .1% .0. 0.." 0 @ 0 C =.@ ". ."C<". ." " @". ""0.@0 " : 3 - )) -' ". 1 " ." C$."0 J " ": )DE*3 &6E)G-+)7-
" . ." .. "" .". . .". ."" " ."C.@.. @%"$. .0. ."0.." ""0.@0 " :%"1" .0"9%""0.@0 .:="3 -G-* .7-
- ."..;..0 .@3 -)+-).7-
. " % 0. C 0". H"% " 1.< "@ C..0 I < .$ .0 .0" 3 - )+ - ' .7-
. "#% .< % " 1.< "@ 0.." " .1. 8 1". 0. $ 1.< " .0. ." $ .$ 0.." " @ .". ." " 11 #/< " @ C..0 I < .$ .0 .0" " @ .00.." "$"@ C. ." &0I0" <.$3 )+-*.7-
- 6 0% C ". " #0 C . ." "@; ..0 . ."" ."% " 00 . =.@ " ;<". ." 0 " ;. C " : ""0.@0 - . ;#0 %; ". ""0.. ."#-6.."#$. I .11. %; ". ".0. ."0.."0".$43 -)).7-
F- C4% . ". 0""<9 :"% 0 $. " ." C.% " .4 1". 'E $. '++F% 0 .0" $ .0. - "
('*))('++, &D())&
" 6 %@.4#.@0 @0 ".$ I .$. " . "0 C .. ." ".@ C. ." "0: ."% .H"-
#0 I % " ." 0"9 C0.." : C.-$.0. C0..""" 8 01. "@C. ." 1" ." $ I 0". ." .- . % 0 ".$ " = C .$. .0" "C. ."0.."3 -)G-).7-
0 $.0. . -""8 0 @. 0 . ""# ." . ".. .@ "C .)+.*.%.@0.."" C1". 0. $ 1.< " .0. ." $ .$- 11 % .4 0 1. 'E $. '++F ..@ $ ": " . ". .<1".$.0. "0""<9:"-
,- 8<0..4#0 C .)).H .1. ".;..0 % @C<.#% ."" ."-
$. .$. 6 8 $< ## .8 "..%". '*H$.'++'%'+0. EH. '++F-6" . " 6 % . $ ." ". $. 0 "0.-6 ": :.". <.H" .". %0.11" ;" ""4- % ' 0: '++F% C. =".. 6 ..@ @C. C . 0"""$0".1. .""##-6 00 C. ." 0 . C:" . 8 ;..0 @.- 6. 8@".%$....". .#.'G0.'++, 1.<8 6 .= *+ 0:'++,"..". ."-
0.4 ;#. $. "" 8 $"" #. @. ".":" ." .. C0.. ."C.& ."#. .""" ."C$."0 - ". %1 C#%".$ 0 C. .""" C..0 $ C""03 -), 7-
" .$. C0.. ."- &. 0# 0.<. I " .$ 1."8 ## $<C. ."<. : C$. 1. 00 -C $1.0 @C.C . ".:"8 "$< ## " $< C. ." @ ."% " @ " 00 . :-
('*))('++, &)+())&
.."C..0 "H .1."..-" % . @ 0". 1.< $. " " 00 C. ." . - 11 %$.;11.00 "0 . . .< 0". " C. " $< .% . "@ 1..4 " 6 - % ;":.# ." 1. 8!!-#/.0. .""A ."" ."& %"0 1. @;." $0#0.. 0 .$0 " % .08<" ".0<.00-
$ @. 4% . H .1. C" "9 < " 4#0 C . )) .% " 1"0 C . "# 0 ". ."H ". ."%". 0C. & ."". ."1..40 :-
$=%.H .1.""#.8.@" . "0 $". ." .$.#!!-#/.%0& #0 0.."$ I ..0 -
"@ " .0 0. . *) 0: '++D " < " " @;. "4 8 C..& 0 -
J- C.. .#%0"0 . KLF++-&0.8=# " 3 -EJ-) * 7 .0. ". KL)C+++-&"3 -EJ-' 7-
- '. '
12$3!4
$:". H ''H.'++,!!- #& /.%#/.2 .%" ..". .$.'G0.'++,M
$34
C0 .0 M
1.<.C..0 *)0:'++DM
0 8=#!!- #/.%#/.2 .%0"0 KLF++-&M
('*))('++, &))())&
".0. KL)C+++-&8!!- #/.%#/. 2 .%8=#C 4$M
. @% "1"00 < . DJ .$ ". 1 C"#. ." H...% I I " %$"."". 0.. .1% H" 4 " .1. ."% &$ .: 1M 00". "". ..@"."%0" .1 0"9$ " .# " ""0 .M.". I ".<0.0". .: 1% )+++ )GM I .4 "." " %.$"@"000"9$%".$ I H". 8C$".M
"00.@ I 8 ! " !#$% $" !!- #/.% #/. 2 .% .. @C 0 " ." =""#.C.1"0 ." 8C"11.1C$."0 -
6.# 5 !0"$9%. %!-9=4%!0K.%!- =.%!0"% H#-
"0 .:0.. .15
#11.4&H. &H-5 $.&. 5 !- "". -"$9
"."1"0 I "00.@< .-
4$% #11.45
('*))('++,