Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATA/633/2005 • CJ GE ATA/633/2005 KI-generiert

Statute's Equal Protection Challenge Based on Classification of Governmental Entities

Geschäftsnummer ATA/633/2005
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Gutgeheissen (Allowed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The dispute concerned the validity of a specific section of a statute, with the central issue being whether that section was facially unconstitutional because it applied only to certain governmental entities, thereby failing to provide equal protection under the law. The court reasoned that the classification created by the statute, distinguishing between governmental entities, was not rationally related to a legitimate state interest, as the statutory distinction served no discernible purpose beyond the differential treatment of similarly situated entities, and thus the law violated the equal protection guarantees of the state constitution.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statute's Equal Protection Challenge Based on Classification of Governmental Entities: The court reasoned that the classification created by the statute, distinguishing between governmental entities, was not rationally related to a legitimate state interest, as the statutory distinction served no discernible purpose beyond the differential treatment of similarly situated entities, and thus the law violated the equal protection guarantees of the state constitution.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
rechtsgleiche Behandlung Verfassung Staatsschutz Statut im internationalen Privatrecht Wahlrechtsgleichheit Rassendiskriminierung

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied to determine the costs of the federal procedure.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

        

       

  

   

 !"#





 $$! %%%%%%%%%%  !"#$$$$$$$$$$%"&#  " 

   





     '()*'

& 

-/   0    -1 2#  (,,.% 3# 3  #  + "4  (,,.%  #5 6##  #&  2   " # 2   !6 $$$$$$$$$$%    !"# $$$$$$$$$$ 7#'89 !6 $$$$$$$$$$ "  6 :# #;""  #8< =#>  /

  6"6  ?@.,,/' 6#<=;!6$$$$$$$$$$/

(/      (1 "4  (,,.% 6#  606 2" <    > #  " % !6 $$$$$$$$$$  A  6 #" "  >6"6  B# # A#    #&#;/  C A"#   A#" #"   #  #"  #& 3 "#  #A#   "# #B 7 D E ,/-,+/(:%  A#;"E#-F 65-11(%##B #F%1  +* " #  #"& "& #"#-FA#-1117  /' E-,-:/ &#%# #B;6 8;6 &#%6"6   #6#   6 #8 6##  #A  +, 2#  -1FG B#  " #   >3 #"## 8"3"6 #8"#  "# #B/

   # 5###%6 &# "A"#B> 3" A   #"  ";66  A##"    #"D  #  #" &##8# ##&"# /

+/   -1  65 (,,.%  6     #&"6 B    #  ;<2;/

&  

-/   > #FH#*"#"6##  #A -(  65 -1F. 7  '  . -,:%  #5 6##  #&      6 #"C  # 3&#"%6"6  #6# 0   2## #"/ 6 #""# 0 "+,2"8 " #&# #""" #/

   >8%  6  " #  A"#  #  # "    3# #">0 # ; A#(12# (,,.%"B# "   >0   -1 2#  (,,.    3#  #6 % "#   + "4  (,,.%< "#/

  6 #" A5/

)+,-.)(,,. '+)*'

(/  ## B  6   "8 '606% #   % #  " #  #" & >#6"  3  "  ; #   6 #8  " I 2###" #" "/

   5 ; "  8A6  > 6"6    " #   > #FH # /E"0 "6 #6 % #B>#  #  #'606  # <  # "%   8 "3  "2< "##" 7&/" / )((.)(,,. -1A#(,,.  )-(-)(,,((G&A#(,,(:/

+/  E>;#    &#3 #"      #6# %  2## #" ## #" > 8 ; "A"# ># #"% B# >  #6#  B  ># # #">5# #7 ).H1)(,,+(+2# (,,+  )--*)(,,( (G&A#(,,(:/

  8;6 # #B6 %#>C>3 #" ##  #6   &#   "    # B# "65  6 #8  "#  "# #B/  #% > # (   8;6  &#3  63#66  >6"6  < ?@-,J,,,/'% A"# < ?@-.J,,,/'   "   #" ##"  #&&#  ##8/

 ># A #  #"&##8#"6  #">6"6 / "< ;"#> B##   6#  >"; # >#6   A   #"  ";66  #"    A##"% " B    3" #  A< #-2A#(,,*/  #8> &&# "  5#  6    6 / '# >3"   #  #"  6#8&&#66 "68 "B>#0 #"# #"  #5  /  #  #" &##8 > 2 ##5 >     # 8&#3 #">6"6 / 6"6;#  #   ## B  >65   2## #" < >#  #" > "#    2;6 " #   # 8/

 %  >8% >&&# A#  " 66  " # <  #  "6 #"" #/" &"A# " " #8""A; #"%B>#& 36#A"#B> B# / 8 "%  "" > 6"6  0  < ?@.,,/' "#  <  A#; #86  63#66  #&  ?@-,J,,,/'   <   #86  63#66 5" ?@-.J,,,/'  86"  =< " # #B">;  >5# #/ &#% #  >C  #   #6 &"%  6  #   B#5&#># 2##B/

*/  "B% 6 #"2 /E" %B#"65%  " &"#  "6 <  6"6  "    "

7 ).F()(,,.+,"4 (,,.:/

)+,-.)(,,. '*)*'

KKKKK

  &  &   

'($)*#!+

 A5  6 #"  (1 "4  (,,.  !6 $$$$$$$$$$ "  >0  #56##  #&-12# (,,.D

$)*,9

2 D

# BJ#J LJ6"6 D

"66#B    0  < !6 $$$$$$$$$$    !"# $$$$$$$$$$%"&#  #5&"#&"6 #"7/.11)(,,.:/

E#; 9 !6"AC%# %!/C=8%!6?#%!/ =#%!6"% 2;/

"6 #56##  #&9

;&&#8'2# 2/9  A#'# 9     !/ ""# /"AC  

"#"&"6 0  "66#B3 #/

 8A%  ;&&#89         

)+,-.)(,,.