Tax Deductibility of Environmental Settlement Payments as Penalties
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertThe case addresses the tax treatment of certain payments, specifically whether they constitute deductible business expenses or non-deductible penalties or fines, arising from alleged regulatory non-compliance related to environmental matters, where the payor argued the payment was a necessary cost of continuing operations and settling contingent liabilities. The court reasoned that the nature of the payment, despite being styled as a settlement or environmental cost, served the punitive purpose of protecting against further violations or losses resulting from past conduct, leading the court to conclude that the payment represented a non-deductible penalty or fine under tax law, as its primary effect was to deter or punish prohibited behavior rather than being an ordinary and necessary business expense.
Legislator-Regeste
AmtlichLICENCIEMENT ADMINISTRATIF; NULLITÉ; DROIT DE LA FONCTION PUBLIQUE; RÉSILIATION; DROIT D'ÊTRE ENTENDU; PÉRIODE D'ESSAI ; EMPLOYÉ PUBLIC | A échéance de sa période probatoire qui n'a pas été prolongée valablement, l'intéressée ne pouvait plus être considérée comme employée. Partant et bien que celle-ci n'ait pas accédé au statut de fonctionnaire, faute d'arrêté de nomination, l'Etat devait appliquer les règles relatives aux fonctionnaires pour mettre fin aux rapports de services. Nullité du licenciement | LPAC.6 ; LPAC.27 ; RLPAC.42
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertCited in the dispositive section to rule on the costs of the federal proceedings.
Cited in the dispositive section to determine the costs payable to the opposing party.
Volltext
!!"###### !" #$#%&'
'
$ %&'&$ &&()
()*+(
&
01 !23444444%'25556 '7%8599 9' 5' 5: ;&% 0++. )../%'5 <
( 0 =5 0++. ,. '&2> 0++,% 2 :''25 >5?@5(;< A%?5 B=5 )B%6 8: 5&5 0..C1 ;> &'22>'%5''> '5!23444444 ''7582'5':> ?5 5995 ' &51!23444444255'' & :# 5''> '51
(020++D)E'F )...% 2 95@5(;< GA% ?5 B#99&5) G B% 6 8: 5&5 0..C1 5''> '5 ''7:5 6'2>>' 25%'72 5 '7:5 2 1!23444444 '229' 5'5%;02)...1 ' 9'5%0+=5)...% & 55 #5#527 '5??:&5 77 ?:57 ;)H'F )... ?2 9 5&5 1 ( 5 : ' 9'5 =25 571 G ?I 6 :'995 ': @5(;< A/' '>)...95?5(5 >5 I 255' & 5 :99 )E 'F )...1 '5 : I 0'&2>)...1
()H'F )...,0'F )..0% 2 :5 5'>5? @5(;< A% ?5 B2J 9'2 5' 0; % 555 57'5 B%65'0)#'#>'251
(50 2>)..0% 2 :''25%:2'5 995 8 5 @5(;< A% % ?5 B=5 )B% 6 8 : 5&5 /. C1 5 5 '952 5' :772 ?:5:755 :B772 ?5 :2'$B ? '5 25 2'5 ' 5 5 2 :51 '5 6 : % 0.=5 )..0%5 5 95 2 5':5 5' B77B!23444444% 2:51 772 9'25 H 'F )..0 : < :# 5 2 5 5 #72 ' 6'59' 5'5G 2:5 5 958 6 '5 2'51 0 '&2> ).., ,0 2> )..-% 8 : 5&5 !23444444 ' % ' 5; #5#5% 6 E.C1 ' 9'5% '5 D ' '> )..-% (5 59'25 !23444444?:&'2>>?:&5 =6 % 595 25 &5 I '5 ; 0 =' :>1 ''> %5!23444444'?I 95)..-95?
*,,-,*)../ (,*+(
:72 5' 8: 5&5 (5'5 ''7=?:,.=5)../1 2 1 ' 9'5% 0+ =&5 )../% 5 72 ''%&:'!23444444%?5''> '5 5;'5 ''7:%'5 =?:,0'F )../%&B 52' '>;2 ?:&5 ' !2 3444444 ' :)..-%?55 52'5>& 5'' 5' 25''> '5B1 ''7 5' '225? : %0E9&5)../6:5 1
)1 :)..-%!23444444 I 25 DH='% % )E =&5 ,0 'F )../% 0E/ ='1 & 5' 25 2 #5#5 &5 ' : @5(;< "" A 0+ =&5 )../% 95 >% 525 5' ?5 5' : ' 5' 9 6 5 5'':5 %?5 5 :'& 2#1
,1 '5)-2)../%"" 59'2 ?:5 '995 :99 5'25'?'I &5 5 = 5951 5 : 5 &57> 6 2'$ 2 '& & 5' 5 &:55 '52'51
-1 0) =5 )../% "" 59'2 ? : :5 : 5 25'7;2 252 5 5' 5&5 '95'1
/1 )+ =5 )../% 5 5 !2 3444444% 5 #5#5? '> ' #25 2 1 :5 5&5 95 5' '> '5 55' &5 I 5 ' :&51 >5 5' '95'% ?5 5&2 ?? 5 5&2 &'?1 '2 5%' $ 5' &5 I 95 5 9&'> 6 '25 5'1#'58 '99 6:5 &'5 5;#K & 5 ' '22 &'$ ' &'5 5 & ' 5#5#5?1 ' ':&'51
D1 :$ 5'!23444444':''7 5' 5''> '55 85 (57 ,'F )../%& 5 ' ' # 0) 'F )../1 "5 6 ' 5 5' : '5!23444444%5 ' 0+'F )../1:$&5 5995 ' '25% 6 :8 5' ' B :$% ' 595 5'B% =7 995 % B'225 5' ' 5 B% =7 >'1 :& 5' ' 5 :2> 5' '> '5%'5 ? 1'22 6 $&5 ?5 5' : 5 '='' 6:& 5' '5 ?!2 3444444255 857958''' 1
*,,-,*)../ (-*+(
!23444444:&'$'2 %59'2:'>& 5'1
E1 (57 )/'F )../%: 25958' &5 5 : ;& !23444444%&99 ,.'&2>)../1
5' 9'5 ''5 8 857 ' :> !2 3444444 ' 25 ''75 1 55' 5 8 '5''> '1
H1 :5 255 ' '5% !2 3444444 ' ; 5> 255 59 ' 55' )D 2> )../% ' 552 6 5 ''7 5' 5' '> '5% 6 '25 5' ?9' 5'5%6: 5'55'55 5' ' &5 6 :' '5 : 525 ' 552 >591 ">5552 % ' 6 5 :I 255' 9' 5'5% 6 5 7 5' 6 :' '5 : 525 ' 552 >59% >5552 % 6 : 5' '7 ' &5' 5' '5 :I 1
&5 '2 5?2 9' 5'5%5' '> '5 '5 5 5&6#,0'F )..- :&5 ''7& 1 &5 =?:''256 59 5' L# ?5 5 5'2>5 255 '% 6 2'2 % '5 5' ' : 5-/;72 :5 5''57 5&' :255 5' ' >52 >5 258 )- 9&5 0+++@/./1.0( A1
''7 5' 5' '> '5 2 =&5 )../ 5 % 5' 85 '& 99 I ''71 ''> % ''7 5' :5 '5> : 5 / ;72 :5 5''5' 5 2 5& 5'' 8 22> ' : >52 #'5 5 0E ' '>0+E+@/0/1.0( 5 A1 99 %>2' '5 :85 5' 5' '> '5 2' 5 6 HD%/ =' 5&5%'5 >5M60H.='& 5'5 5'1
' % !2 3444444 :&5 &>2 9' 5'5%?:&5 ?5 52 ;G02)...1 :I 255' '5: 0'&2>)... 5 % 9' 2255'%585 95 1
+1 '>& 5' )E ' '> )../% : ' = '1
: 55'5?5 F5 &5 25''> '5 '5 >' 5 '5 6 55' '25 5'% '5 6 5'
*,,-,*)../ (/*+(
' &5'5 '6''7 5'5''> '51:&5 595 5' 5 &52572 95 5& > ' : )..-1 (5 &5 :5 ' ' ' 6 ''7 5'1 '& ? 5' '> '5:&5 I &>2 ''7&5 ;':&5' 5' ;7>'9'51'7 5 &>1
!23444444&5 ' 9' 5'5?5)...% ' 9 :&5 =25 95 :'>= : ?'? 21 % 9 :5 ' 9M' '5> 95 ? : 5&5 :572 '5 5 : ' ? 9' 5' ? 9' 5' & '5 :5 5'>5?955 :'>= :;72 5' 55;1
8 5' ' % 5 5> >5 5> :)..-=61
552 5 '' 5'% '>;2 5' ' 5 572 65 5'' '2 6 '&5'2 '95'1%' =5 6/.C &55&5 '' :&5 ' 1
'5 :I ' &5 %&5 5' '> '5 &5 ? 5 9'25 : 5 5'5? 5 &5>655''25 5'' 5'' &5 : 5 B5 5'&'952 5'B1552 &5 '55''> '5 5 5781
0.1 ':5'2 5'' 5E=5)..D% !'5444444%#9&5:255 5' 7 5'' #25 6 : % ? 7 : '>' : : 9' 5' 255 5& 2 6 9' 5' :572 955 $ 2 5?2 :'>= : I 255' ' 5 9' 5'1'>' ?5='575 2 5 ? 655 7 ?:2'$1:$&5 ' 9 '5> %5%5: 1
& $
01 = 2 5 & =55 5' '2 % ' &>@ 1/D '5:'75 5'=555))'&2>0+-0( ( )./N 1D,105 1'5'255 5&0) 2>0+H/( ( /0.A1
*,,-,*)../ (D*+(
)1 5 57 75 '5 7 5& ' :255 5' ' >52 >5258-2> 0++E@ (/./A1
>5 752=55?599 ?5'95 ' &5 5''> '5 ;(5@ 1)0 A1
'&5 ;' 2552'2 '552 %'5 )/'F )../%!23444444 5 '2'$5''> '5''1
,1 ' ' 5 :&'5' 9' 5'5?5 0 2 )...% '?: 77 % ?5 :57 9'2 5'%)H'F )...,0'F )..01
"': 505- %9' 5'?5;& '5 :5 5'>5?D'&2>0+-.@( 00.A%9' :'>= : 72 5'51'?:'>' : '256%5 :85 '5 5''75'6 5 59% @ !*,)*)../)E&5)../A1
'? ' &' '5 ' 5&5 '95' & :572 %:552 #7 &5 2 % 255 75275>1 :I '256 ':I 6%? 77>95 : ' :57 1 ' >5 ' 9' 5'51
-1 ' &5 55' ''7 5' 5' '> '55: 0E9&5)../1
1 5 : 55' 5' ' ?5 9 55'99 &57&125;2 %&5'5 I 7&% 5':52' '2&5'%'5':755 1&5' 5':'2' 5 5'9'2 %' 5 6 575 #25%:;7:'75 5'' 5%' 5 1 ' %&5'5 I :255'5 '5 7&2 5 '5 15 I 5&'? ' 2 & ' '5 % 5&5 55: '5 9'2 #'5@1!%'5 255 59%&'1%)1%)..)%1,.D% ,.E ,00A1
>1 "': 5D % 2'$22>'75?5 '25 5' '> '5 @10A1 '25 5' ?5 9' 5'55 &5 ;77 2:5''> '5, %'&''7 5' 5;@ 1-E1) A1
*,,-,*)../ (E*+(
: 5/ 5 '?5''> '5 I ''71 ' 22 :I % 28522% :>% ? ?: '5 2' 59% 0H. =' 5&5 , 1 '25 5' '5>% 55% ? 5 >%??:'5 2' 59% D.='5&5 ''7 5' 5' '> '5 @ 1 A1 5' '> '5 72 I ''7%8 5'2 :28522% 5'5995 @ 1A1
:;%' 77?5 :2'$ ;0 2>)..01:#5''> '5'55 ' 5 & ,0 'F )..-1 G' ' ?:6 % 2''7 5'5''> '5: 5 &%52I2%& 5; '5% : &'? & :5 ' 5; & 5'% 2 55 % 2' 5 2'5 9&5 )..,1 85 5'9'5 '= 595 5 5'('5 :> '25'>5&55'=55?%5:'75 5' 5 5' 5 9 5(5 '22 5 7 151% ' >%5 %' %(' 5 ' 8 :255 5' '5&'?: ;&1
55' ''7 5' 5' '> '5 5 & 0E 9&5 )../(2 '&$ 5'%&5' 5': 5 / 5 %( 55 5&1':$ 75;2 5&5% ''7 5' 5' '> '5 1 52' 6 7 ? 95 % #5#5 5 &' 5 '2 5 5' ' '>' 51
'? % ' '5 I '5 '22 : 2'$5''> '56 ' 552 1"5 5 &'5 '22 '? :; '2 5? 9' 5'5% 9 :I '25 5' '5: @ 1-E A%5: 2'5 ? 5' % : '5 5 '' ;7 5> 8 9' 5'5 2 5; 95 ' &51 &55 552 '5 55 I 825 7 5'5 5' 5>8552 '';5''> '5@ 1)0) N *,00*)../0D&5)../A1
/1 1 &'5 ?:5 I 25 95 8 ' &5 ; 5' '> '5 ' 2' 59 '>= 5&2 9'% F2 ' % 2' ?'5 ' &5 59955@ 1)01 )5 1> A 555 5'1
>1 555 5' '52'5'95:2'5;'? ' &5' :@ 1).1, A1
*,,-,*)../ (H*+(
:;%55 5' &)D'F )../',.'&2> )../%0E.;2=':55 ' &555 '25)E =&5 )../1 '7 ' &>2 '225? 5 #' 5' ' 5'% ?5 :; +. =' @ 1 ,,D 5 1 > 5>&'5: 1-- A1
1 '5 955 '22 2' 59 '>= 5&2 9'< :5995 5'N 2?2 7& ' 8 &'5 &5 ' :5 5 625857' @ 1)) A1'? '5 : &5755 ' &5' 2' 59%5'5 ' ''?I 255 5&@ 1)E1) A1:5 59'2 :?I ;''& '955 '5' #'5819'5:?I #&%5 :852' :?I @ 1)E1, / A1
55% ': 5&5% J '22 '?'' &5' 5''5 '8'8 9' 5'5 % 5? 5 '75% ' '5 :I 1
D1 '5 :I %7 582 : 5)+5) ' 5 5'9 '9 5'50H&50+++@ 1("0.0A 7 5 6 ; 9'2 ' &5' 5' '5 55 J : 5' 55' ?% 522 # ' 9' @ G 00+ 0,D '51 )>A1 &5' 5' ' 9'5 > & :5 ' 5 (5 ='5 2I2 '&'5 :82 ? 5' 5 575 ? : '5 5 52 5 :82 ? 5' ;&:'' 5 %: '5 ' '> 5 ' '&'5 :82 6 5 : '5 25; 5 @ I 5> 9)1,.*)..,)=5)..,'51)1- I 5 N *E.,*)..) 0+'&2>)..)A1
% 5> 255 59 5' 2I2 '&'5 '75 5' ? '5 : % 2 : 55' 552 & :'' 5 # 6 ' 82 @ 1 D0 1 ) A1 55 2'5'5 :I ' (I >55 '1 '?%552 ' 1 :5 95 '=' 5 ' :255 5' '1
E1 '55251
2'2 OG0:...1(256#7:'995' : 1 ' %525 OG):...1('6' %6 #7: @ 1HE A1
*,,-,*)../ (+*+(
PPPPP
'%&$ &
*+!, -
&> ' 5 = )D 2> )../ !2 3444444 ' 55':'995': )/'F )../N
!,-
:2 N
' 5 55'552 )/'F )../N
2 6#7:'995': 2'2 OG0:...1(N
'6' 525 OG):...1(6#7: ;&N
'225? I 6!" #$#%&' ' 55?:6 :'995': 1
"57 < !1$#;%5 %!2'&$ O5%!1 #5%!2'% =71
'2 5>255 59<
7995;(=5 < 5 < 15'("575 G1$#;
'5'9'2 I '225?8 51
;&% 7995;<
*,,-,*)../