Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATA/536/2006 • CJ GE ATA/536/2006 KI-generiert

Agency Deference in Public Fund Management Review

Geschäftsnummer ATA/536/2006
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Abgewiesen (Dismissed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The appellate court reviewed a dispute concerning the scope of statutory authority related to the management of certain public funds or assets, specifically addressing whether a prior administrative decision regarding the allocation or disposition of those assets was subject to full judicial review or limited deference. The court reasoned that the governing statute clearly delegated discretionary decision-making power to the administrative agency within defined parameters, and absent a clear showing that the agency's action was arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with law, the court should defer to the agency's interpretation and factual findings, thereby affirming the agency's determination.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Agency Deference in Public Fund Management Review: The court reasoned that the governing statute clearly delegated discretionary decision-making power to the administrative agency within defined parameters, and absent a clear showing that the agency's action was arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with law, the court should defer to the agency's interpretation and factual findings, thereby affirming the agency's determination.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
richterliches Ermessen Staatsorgane Kognitionsbefugnis Amtsmissbrauch Verwaltungsvermögen Verordnungsbefugnis

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Costs are imposed on the losing party.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext



        

        

 

   



 !"#





#!"$$$$$$$ 



% & %% ''%% %&( ' 





     !"# 

% 

'(  )* +++++++, -  +++++ './0,  1***- 2 34(   **561**6*!71*!&&!(

!(  8  * 6* 6  4*  19*    4*:* ;* 63<8 =>*59?,!0619!&&#,5* 61*6*1*,*@@34*4'. 1%?*!&&#(

%(   *  '! 9 !&&#, )( +++++++  1- 2 64* -661*'$1*!&&$,A**61*6:6* 164( **,*63* *1*1 4*6>*B>>*4(

  '%9!&&#,8 6-65@-*1 '$1*!&&$(

  )(+++++++-6-61*8 ? 2(

7(  1C1?,2'.B7#,5*--**>*54 B@  **     34(   B  B1*  *  ,  4* A*  6--* 5 *119**- 2  *:** 1*( )(+++++++*4*2**>>*566-4***, -6*5>*:-:*A(

  :-6:1,)(+++++++**A-A5*4*-6  61*  * 63  8 ( >*,  * 6* >>  1*1(

#(  94*!&?*!&&$-8 ,)(+++++++  6*:1*,5:*26*A*6*A 1-6**>>(?*2*6B6* *54*9*-A5*-6-*(>*54* *'$1***:9,*46   6  >1 2  -**  5*-(   **- 5*: 

8 (

$(  C-7?*!&&$--@-*9,8  *-61**)(+++++++6A*D1*,66** 5*'$*>--***3'!-19'.#0 ;8 /7'(&'   =( 5*-- -* *- 2 *  4-B*  -:* 6-* E,   )   4-B* 6 A  61*  *5-*6-*6-*(

"!$%%"!&&$ %"# 

/(  )(+++++++** *91***>5'/?*!&&$ 2-*-1(6*:1* -*  **   9* 6>*  B>> *4  6*DD,  1 - 6  16F,    >* A5* 5:** 51-6*65*B*(4*1C1-4-4-B* *1*-27#G1"B3'/1*!&&$(

0(   6*  --   16* 6  7 619 !&&$(

 ( )( +++++++  >*1-  (  5-* -1 16-   -95@-*1,*6*A511*'$1* !&&$21**(31*,***4-B**1*-27#G1"B( 54* 6   --6*- A* * 4* -- 1*  8 ( 8  6 6>*,6*4*61**6*5-16931(

 9(  8   6*-   -**,  A5* 5:** 5 *  *(  5-* --  1**11 -:  *  4 *6** A* 6-4F* A  4 *  9** 2 *  * 1*-?26-(

% ' 

'(  ?-  16 * 4  ?*** 16-,    49;(#$ *H:**?***!!419'.7'    !&#I($%('(*6-1***4'! 619'.0#    #'&=(

!(  ****>*:42 ;('$( '(> =(

%(  63*>*:4,61***-6D 1*1**11*,*A-6--,61*--*- >**5*>*:42@6**5*>* 1F1 :4 ;( '$ ( !    =( >*, 5*- %   *6** 6-4* A  -  *  61*  * 5 *>* 4*-25*-',>,9*2-*(

   563,     6 4* *  4-B*  A5*-**,*A5*>*59?,!0619!&&#,5* 61**6@*>*:4*-1F,1

8 6-5@-*'$1*!&&$( >*,***>*A5* 5611**>*1*3**,1*A5*51-6*

"!$%%"!&&$ 7"# 

   2 6*  A  * 4* >>*>,   A  8  *J16-12*(

   *9 1***> 34 A      1: 566- **A**>--,8 4**16:4*- >( >*, 5*-  4* 6 6  -:*:  --1 2 -B:(>>-*9A5*56-*B, B3A4*-**4-B*9*-A5**:- A* 6 11   -6  '/ 1* !&&$(   *,  *9 1***>-*-12D1*(

7(  4A*6-3,6*11*(5* **:,-11 KE!&&( 1*2B:,A*9* 6*1:*(-11 KE!&&( -:1,1*2 B:8 ;(0/ =(

)  %'  %   

*+,- .

-49*?-'.?*!&&$6)*+++++++ -**4*19*4*:*7?*!&&$** 61**6A*D1*I

,-#.

516*1I

>*1-**8 A56*61** )(+++++++I

>*@-12D1*I

12B:-11 KE!&&( I

12B:8 -11 KE!&&( I

* A, >1-1 @ * ./  *4   * >-- H:** ?***,6-C6C6-,64**1***>,   ? 3  *>**, 6 4  *9 >--I  1-1*  ***A*,1*>1F646*: 1*I**C-*@16*1*

"!$%%"!&&$ #"# 

*9 >--, '&&&  '7I  6- C   6*3  6*  ,*4A-111F64,*4C?*2H4*I

11*A6-C2)*+++++++**AH4*19* 4*:*2H>>*>--2(

8*-:< )14F,6-*,))(FB3 B-*,?:(

1 *91***><

:>>*3 ?*<  4* 6-*<     (* 8*:* (4F  

6*>1C--11*A-@6*(

 34,  :>>*3<           

"!$%%"!&&$