Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATA/495/2006 • CJ GE ATA/495/2006 KI-generiert

Appeal of Denial of Statutory Relief

Geschäftsnummer ATA/495/2006
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Gutgeheissen (Allowed)
Kostenauflage zulasten Vorinstanz / Staat

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The case concerns an appeal by a litigant challenging a judgment that upheld the denial of their request for relief, which appears related to certain statutory provisions regarding property interests or contractual obligations, as evidenced by multiple cross-references to other sections of the law and the repeated citation of statutory language throughout the decision. The court affirmed the lower court's decision, reasoning that the appellant failed to demonstrate that the lower court abused its discretion or made an error of law in denying the requested relief, finding that the appellant's arguments did not establish a basis for overturning the prior determination, particularly concerning the application or interpretation of the referenced legal standards.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Appeal of Denial of Statutory Relief: The court affirmed the lower court's decision, reasoning that the appellant failed to demonstrate that the lower court abused its discretion or made an error of law in denying the requested relief, finding that the appellant's arguments did not establish a basis for overturning the prior determination, particularly concerning the application or interpretation of the referenced legal standards.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Auslegung von Urteilen gesetzliche Grundlage Beschwerdelegitimation Obligationenrecht Einrede der Verfassungswidrigkeit Unterlassungsklage

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Provision governing the allocation of court costs applied in the dispositive.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext



        

        

 

    

 !







""""" ##  !!"#$%&'(% 

% 

$% % $ & ' % $    $   ( 





     )*+,)

 

01  233333 41 1 5")67 8 " %  % 9     " %&"%" %:; %;""" %6(14%< '  =8" %  &"   %;;'  ; ""7 ";%  "%   >%  "%  ;%<""  <' &;    % "% ?   "% @ "&1

*1   0,,A' 8 "  "& 6  8%BB"  %  8" "%     "%  (" 5")67 8   % 8" ";9  &&;  C    & %B"%   <D'  %;;   "1   &&;  %(E" *//0 E"*//F1

  8 "%< %;<>;D<" "BB   ; 8  6('""="6(1

G1  0,,A 0,,H'8  BB >% I="% ( %" "B14" C";%  (%; 8 "'8  %C %(% I*//0'="(%<6;; "6 ; ("1  " "%  8 "     "B%;      "("  C  %B%;&1

  6 *//*' 8    J  "  ;  8" ;%:  8 "1 ;*//G'= "6;% I%" "% ("  BB   8  1 4%  "'  % I %  ;"  ;   ;"6  %<6; % % "  ;%  ;&;  "" =8 ; "6    ("' 8D ; " %  "  %&' % ;; 1  %    <%D   % 6 ""&   8  '%%%;%; I %1

.1  *,E"*//F'8  %"="6;% I>B"("B"     8 "  &   <D1  %  %  8" "%  A E" *//F = 8 "  "%"   8 &"   D (" =%   (" B"D"(" K  ;%"B"%;<>%" 1

   %"  0* E"  *//F' 8     %= %""   8 "% "%8 "%;<8;  "6'% ;;  &" D ("'"  (": =" 8 " *//.'""= "B" "%%   (" : ;%"B" "%   B"D  "1 8" "%  > ;%:  8 "  "   ";1

+-.,+*//- )G+,)

  6 (%" J  0F  ;< *//F  " %; ' 8    %"" 0F%(;<*//F8 "=8 "B"%(>%    ("   ;%:' B" =8" %"   %B%;"  (  & %B"%"<1" B">C8 "G/%(;<*//F %=8%"%"%   ("L; %"&'    "&""=%; D (" %;%:% ;%"8%L C% %<*//F'% "& ("1

F1  " 8 %C ;1 %='8   %;;"= C 8 "'  %"  */ ;< *//F' =8" %""  =&%B"%8 "  ' =8"8 " 6% %"<  "( 8   "% ;   C 8 "  %;""%1 B%; "% %=8""%" % E(" *//-1

   %%8"  "%8 "1

-1   ""%  0, E(" *//-' 8    B 8   "% "  C 8 "1   "   "(   %;"  %;;   "   8 "  &&C &%B"% 1 8("    &&; ' " " "%  & %B"% 8    %<(1 4% B  %% C 8"  "%  %"    %"  "6%"" ; " %%) &%B"%1

  "8  > " B">%"( % %(    "%1;"%B%;" %" <" ("'%<E 8% 6' " % (1

    "% %("   " K  "  % ( 6 8"   %M 8 " "   ;  %( =  & %B"%  %;; "("   % % 8&&; 1

A1      */ B(" *//-' 8 "  " E  % %    ""% 6  "< ;""  "B1  "% 8 D&  (" ";%  5;") ;<*/%(;<*//F9'%C K ;" %%&" %;;"5*.%(;<*//F0/E("*//-9' 8("   % "  C  =K   8    0F %(;< *//F1  (D' %     "B%; "%    "B" "% >"&  ";   8   ("    ;" % BB 1  ""%  "  "%% "% <"('8  =8  "(" "; ""  G ; *//- %   %<( "%  E   %<6; %&" "%    "%1 8"  "%    8 "  % %"  ;" ""%=("%" %%" 8K  1%N '" 8&"" ;"6B%"=% ' D" '8(" %C ; C 8" ";  %;  %D" '     "% 8 %% 

+-.,+*//- ).+,)

"%  % CB"  ""1 B"' "%8("% "%(%" "&;  ( C 8 " *.   %"  8" "%     "%  ("  0* ; *//. 5  )   0 /F9  "  8; (  8 " .-  ' %B8   "%'8 ".F 1

  % (C8"%%%; "% "% %""   8  ' "" =  %   ""("  ("1  (D'  (  D ("  %  ;%: %  ;%" 8%L C% %<*//F8%  %" 1

H1  8" ";  %  %  0 ;" *//-1 " *//0'  "( % I BB   8   ("  ( 8>"  8"B "% > &%B"% %"1 "B "%;("   %%<%   ;%"&&  " " ;%:   % 1 ;"  &"B   B=  B"&"   %<6; " C    ("    %  ;%:1  %  8("  8" %E%  B%"(D ("'=""  % % I  & %B"% ";%"<   %"   ""6;  "<1  "'  ""%  " ; "%"  >;   %"<""   >;"   "% " "  %  ;% "  8(%"  %;;" 8"B "% > & %B"%'  B%"   ;  %"" 1  B" %"=; % " 1

 $ 

01   E   ;  " (   E"" "% %;  '  %   (<5 1F- %"@%&" "%E"""%(;<0,.0)  )  * /F ?  1 -G 1 0  1    %"   % ;""  "(  0* ;<0,HF) ) F0/91

*1  4%8 "*F ' %  "%;" &' ( 8"%" "%&%&; "'%" """&6 8%BB"  &&;      &1 8%BB" "( C 8 " 8   "% %% ' 8  ";" 1 8&&;   BB   E%"&  ( %8;<%%1

  > ;  8 " .F " 0  ' %=8  " ("  8 "*F  &'8%BB"""%B "(8   "%("  "14%B= &("    ("% "%  &' 8%BB"   B  "(  %  %(    "%% %";%"C"=5 1.F1* 91

   86' " 8   %      " =  %    %;" &%B"%'8 "*F 1:

+-.,+*//- )F+,)

% B%"" "&B" (%""&("&%    "  "%(C8 ".F 8"=1

G1 1 4%8 " ' "%  %<%C%   "%  B"    % =8 " %"  );K;'   %M  %"%" ""= (   %"1 8 " *.   % = 8 %"    "("    " C  "&' % ;;   %"   "6   %"% % C  %%   B"  %   % &    B">  " C  BB 1 8 %"  " "<;  8 "  8  " =" B  %"  "6%8""=%M)" %(1

 <1  8%' " %   %" =  %  8  B%" C 8 %" " ";8;<"B%; "%="1  ""'=" %&" D ("'%  "B%"  %;   0* E"  *//F1 8:   %<  "  &"   8 "' 8  DB%"" % "%;""(0F%(;<*//F1  8<   "%' 8 %"  " ";  ( "  % '  */ ;< *//F'=8""%" % E("*//-'&C%)

% "%"6>"&1"6%"" 8:  %" ' ""%%  %% "0,E("*//-1

  8 =%=% (%"  ""6% % "% " ="";%"E" *//F1  < "  "B  D BB  8' %   ' %E%    (  %"1 '   (' >"&    " *   .  O%;  B   %" "% ("   "%%"&C6(%   "  %;;   "P' =" B6   &     %;;   "'    8 " AG  8%% 0  "( C  %"   ("  0/ ;" */// 5  0 Q 4 H10009'    ;  ";%      "  % ;  C 8    ("B"      %   &&; "1

  ( 8 "*. "*  '8   %(" 6%"<;  "8 " % 1

 1 4%8 "-0"0 '% K B%;% ;; % ("% "%%" ':%;"8>6 8<%(%"8" "%1

   86' 8 %"  " "; 8 ;  <  % %(%" 8" "%< ""%%  ;=; >& %B"%BB %8=K *,E"*//F1  " "%  B%  8<  % "% 8 %;  " ";%   %  % I &%B"%=(D ("'

+-.,+*//- )-+,)

;&      ( "; '  =" %("  K  %" %;;  %B"; "%("% "%&% 1

  &;  "6%=%)% "%"6 %""  8>"="    D&  ("  %("=  1 "  D&  ("   8" " ( <" 6  ; "" "  8  0*E" *//F1 ; '%;;""%0,E("*//-  %"&'  % "% ;K; "(  "6  "  ; "  C  %   %""   >;    ""%1 '      %%'%=% B"(%" " "6="'&" D ("8 %E%  B%"' =8%%;"%=";KD"  % "%1 %" "%'  %   BB  %  8=K   *, E" *//F   8 "  <=    %   %""  8   C %" =  & %B"%8("   1

.1 1 % B" &; &"BC""% "("%%%"  8K   '  ;% "B = 8    " '  ;%;   8% "%   ""%=' %E% "8" "= "%&" D ("'"G;*//-": 8" "; "%% % ;; C %<; "=1

 <1 =8" & "8 "*,"* % "  "%B %B "% "  0H (" 0,,, 5  1 Q 4 0/09'  %"  8K    %; % ;;   %"  %   "  B" (%"  %"   ( (  =8 ""%  %"  "'  B%"  ( =  > B"     C "B   ""%' 8(%" 6  %"'   "" C 8;""  "%('8%"  ;"C %%5 K  "<B*1AA+*//G,E" *//G'%"1*10  K " ? +*,A+*//-G/;"*//-91

 1 8&;  %;< % B%" C B>1  %  ;&  BB   % "(B8   "%'% " ""= "%' % 6 =" %        " %;  %"  <"' %   "<;""  "B8 ""1  %%% % I&%B"%5D"  9';"%  = "%  "%;%" <"5 6("" D"  91

  "% '8  8("%%" 8K   % '"; " C "6"% "C8% "% ""% "" = % %"  %;   " C   % %1"% "'% ;" %"<"" %"'  BB"'(;= 14"8:%" '%

+-.,+*//- )A+,)

%;% ;  8   "; < C 8 %"  " ";1   '  %"  8K   % 8 ("%1

F1 1  %  B"  " &"B C  ""%  0, E(" *//- 8(%" "= C %  8 " .F  '  N  %;;  "%  B  8   "%'"8 ".- '"<C("% "%(%" "&; 1

 <1 4%8 "*. ' "8<D%%;"=%8 %B"%  =  =K  ("  C %    &   ; %  B%"C8%BB" % % "'%" "% (8 ".- %"1(;K; "%"> "& "8%( "%% "(1

  868 ".- '% ( "%>"%" "%8%   %" ="  B%   8%<E  8 ="B" "%  %   "%   ; ;""  "(    $2 0//1) C F@///1)' C %%  8%BB"1

   = "%   %  (%" " 8 " *.   8"=   86   "   "% C "= C  %  "  L K  8; ;""  "((C8 ".- 1

 1 8 "*. % %;; " ;&"O(%""&P1  (%" %' %  >  "   "%" "%'  =K  ("  C O%  P  & 8 <D %%;"=1  8"" '   : ; "= &' E  6  "%" "%  8 " *G  ' " "  O %   "%  &P1    " (%"   %;   8   %  <"  %;  =" B6    %" "%  ("      "% %"  & C 6( 5 =8" %("  8  O&P91 4% 8 "*G"*  'B"%   &'8  <';" 8 ; '  %""%=K ; 6 "1

  8 " *.   (%"   %= 8%<"& "%  "&   "6=8   C;=K <   %    &  ("&1  ("% "%  (%"  "& % 8 "*.  N "%(8 ".- 18 " *.    "  K  %;" %;; B%   (%"  "& 8  " %  8   %J%"  =8      &1   '8%<"& "%"&%6&& '"" =8"    (  D 1   " *.   .-   8%  C   &  % 1

+-.,+*//- )H+,)

  8 %"  " ";  "  % <" D<""  C %%   "% ( 8 ".F  &"B%= &; E 1

-1 1 % 6&%= "%"B"&("%"" %% "%" '  % B%"  :   &; 1 %    =  &"B  ("% "%  ""   %% "%"  %        "%'  "<;""  "B%"%;;"B%1

 <1  "" %;%  " "%;  %"  1 8<%'  ;%: D%"" %"  K  % C  "  <  B"> 56& 8 " 91 >"6;; '  ";%: '%%" D%"""="% 8 " ;%" &(>" K "(56&" 91 B"'%%" ; <  BB    ; D%""   "  "%  8;""  (     %;   %"   (  8" K  <" 5%% "%"     %"   ;95B1 20*G00*%"1.10*0 K " 91

   86' %  (%"  &6  =%"  B  "( %     "%    "%  >   ;""    %" "%1 8"'   "% %"  K  (' (%" (' % 8  '  8D:% D6 %M  %  % "   ( =8     & %B"%  % 8 "("  &&; "1

A1  8"" "&';%;  $20@F//1);"CD& % '="%;<5 1HA10 91  RRRRR

'% $        

)*+,-!.

 (<  % " E   */ B(" *//-   233333 41 1 %   ""%  8%BB"  %  @" "%     "%  ("  0, E(" *//-?

+,-/.

E ?

; CD&% ;%;  $208F//1)?

" =8"%8";" ?

+-.,+*//- ),+,)

%;;"=    K  C ! !"# $%&' (%    %  "" =@C 8%BB" %@" "%  "% ("1

4"& 7 !1:D6'" '!;$"'!1 D"'!;%'E&' !1 'E& 1

%; "<;""  "B7

&BB"6)E" E17  " 7     !1 %%" 21:D6  

%"%B%; K  %;;"=> "1

 6('  &BB"67           

+-.,+*//-