Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATA/443/2006 • CJ GE ATA/443/2006 KI-generiert

Property Boundary Dispute Over Sequential Conveyances

Geschäftsnummer ATA/443/2006
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Teilweise gutgeheissen (Partially Allowed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The case concerns a dispute over property boundaries, specifically involving sequential conveyances from a common grantor, where the description in a later deed was argued to encompass a larger area than intended due to an ambiguous reference point. The court reasoned that the subsequent deed's boundary call, which referred to a monument or line that was already implicitly fixed and controlled by the prior conveyance, must be interpreted as incorporating only the portion of the property not previously conveyed, thereby limiting the later grantee's interest to the remaining, unencumbered land to preserve the integrity of the earlier grant.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Boundary Dispute Over Sequential Conveyances: The court reasoned that the subsequent deed's boundary call, which referred to a monument or line that was already implicitly fixed and controlled by the prior conveyance, must be interpreted as incorporating only the portion of the property not previously conveyed, thereby limiting the later grantee's interest to the remaining, unencumbered land to preserve the integrity of the earlier grant.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
gemeinschaftlicher Teil Liegenschaftsgrenze Mehrbelastung einer Dienstbarkeit Streitgegenstand Grenzstreitigkeit zwischen Staaten Erschliessungspflicht

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied to order the appellant to pay the procedural costs of the federal court.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext



        

        

 

      

 





 !"#$" $%&" '()   !  "#$% 

% 

')  ))' * + ') 



)' , , )  * )     +   !"##-!  # !%!&$#$% 

 

 !"#.!%# //"01".)  # !'' '#$% 



     ()*+,(

 

+1  !%' (2 3%    4%'   &'%  %5' !'&#%55!''1

   ' #' "6'7"'865 % ' %5'1

)1  %' '55%"''9%5'!'&:1 1;'(9<:11=  %' '2%  '$' 1

   '6:11%'  ''5 2 "'(6%<

 ( >,)%55?@

 ( >+//)%55!''@

 (   > +.0A   %55  !''# 7 6''  ..B)./5)#2 %$ 3C !'&#76 .D.5) 5"3'  "C '5 2' % 5@

 (   > +.0-   %55  !''# 7 6''  )E,7E,D-5)2'"' '2"C '5 % 65..-5)1

   %$  % F%&'%1

,1   ++5')//.#!%'GH%'!2'!%' ' %( 55  :$%'  % '   ' ( '%   :11 %  '4 &%" IG+,B0//B///1(1

.1   )- % %" )//.# %  5  % $% #  :11  %''  2  %55''% 6%'9 &'% ;'(9<  G  %  %55''%= %%  '$''%%+.0A +.0-#'%%('' ''2%(J '5 %$>+-+E8%'6 %' 6%'.% %"+DD+;GK:)++1.+)1++=1

  %$'$''%%'' 8''%>+.0A4 %(%+.0A  +.0A15'9#76'')07))E5)# &%"'  %   6 '5% 8 7&' # % 2  4'95# 7 6+DB/+.5)%5' % '%'' '% $% '% &'%$' L 5' 1

  '$''%%'' &5 8''%>+.0-4 %(%+.0-  +.0-15'9#76'')0-B/005) %$'   $% '% &'% % 2  4'95# 7 6'' 

*,-,.*)//0 (,*+,(

0B0-.5)# ' '5%87&' $27' ' %%&5  6%L %$  '%1

  6' #:11%'' ' '%%(% +.0A  +.0- %>+-+E#76'',/B-+/5)# %( %+.0A +.0- %>+-+A#76'')AAB/ED5)1

01  ''%)0J$')//0# G 2L '$" 5% '6 27 7$'    %" '  '&5    '% ' $    :11   !1 ! 5    % M ' ('  '  J ' % %8G1

E1   +. $' )//0#  :11  ''  G  7 %$ 2L 1  %'' '   %   '% 2  '%  ' ( '% 7$'   8 L   %' 9 % 2   '6 7 '    '5  &'%1 %  #'%'%2L  1

   :11 4%'  27 %3' '  &$  %'  7 3?% 392 8 % IG)B///B///1(#'%%2%'' ' 6'' '%   %    '  %' '      %"J '$5  '%' 8 7&' #  2' '5'2'   '$''%#  %  ('   F%&'%1

  7'5#:11%' % 74 '%   '6%' 1% ' 2$ %  '6%'   '   '5 8 IG +,B00D7D0)1( % 2    '6 8 $% '% &'%  '  '58 IG0B.D/BD0)1(1:7&'  '# '95 ' F% &'%#  4  $'   ''# %6%55  8   '2 %  #  %66''  3%'2  /#)  %  4 6  3 ' ' 4'   6'4$59 8 IG.//1(#% ''$ 3%'27 '8"C '2'' 7% IGE//1(59 1

   %2 #  :11  '  %' ' 7 '6 &'% 2'   ' 2./#0)N % ' $%'1 ''#%% '%  '6 &'%    '6' 8 0/ N#   '6   :11  %' '   ''5  '%'55"&'%1

A1  EJ')//0# G %8 %   '# 8 $%' !1 !   % %# 75''     :11         G 1    %'%# ('  %   2  %J   '$''% '%     :11 5&'   5'9 2   $  %5' &'% 2' '     %'    2'  '  J ' 8  G1

-1  )+J')//0# G ''%J''2 %  '  2  '%  ' ( '%   :11 7 '   %5' 8

*,-,.*)//0 (.*+,(

 %' '%#"'('7  %5%%5%'0/N7  '&'%1

D1   %%  %'  5L5 J%#  G # %    27 7 ' %5  % %''$''%'%%'' # 5' %'   5   B5&5 #  B2'5     %&5  ;'( 9<    %   5 # $ ' %   5   %  '%  3%%&'B'6%5 '%@'(9< =%''% 7 '.G $'7&' ;'(9<$'=  5   7' '#  7&'     7$'%5  $ ' % 5  ' %';'(9< =#%27'  5 '$''%'%%+.0A +.0-1

  ' ''%7 % '6'8!1 3% 1

+/1  %'0J' )//08 G #!1 3% #%5 % $% # 7  2' 7 $  % %   $   %5'1

    3 # ' %3' '  6' $%'  %'   5 '%  65' 2'%6' 7 '.AG1

++1  +/ %O )//0#$'#"%'5  '%' 6%':11# %'7% '%'$''%'%% +.0A  +.0-1

+)1  +0%O )//0# 5 %  2%  '%'    > +.0A  '  %6%5 4 '%' '% &  5 '9 75&5  ' %'1  ' &5 %>+.0-#8 74 '% 7 "2 %    5  $'  % 8 4'&  5%' '%$%' 1

+,1   +,  5" )//0# !!1 !   3%  %       %5 '%% G 1

  !1 3%  '6%53%%%&'$5 ''% ' ( '%1

  '4'22'' '%%"'8655 '  '  '%'66'' 27'%3' ' 6'$%'%' 5 '% &'%1

   G   %6'5 8 !1 3%  27 ''% J'' $'      )+ J' )//0 %    2  '%  ' ( '%   :11 7 ' %5'8 %' '%1  ''%'' % '6'%6%55  87 '-,')G1

*,-,.*)//0 (0*+,(

+.1   ''%  5L5 J%# H     )D  5" )//0  !1 3% #  G   %%  J '5     > +.0A # %5     ''%  $'  +/ %O  )//01   ''%  +,  5" ' 4''%J'' 7%% %'  G )+J')//01

+01  ++% %")//0# G ''% '6' '$2 %%H' J '5 >+-+E#''% %(%+.0A  +.0-1

+E1   ,+ % %" )//0# !1 3%   ' J  % 9  '" 5''  '6 %   ''% J''   7%%  %'   G )+J')//0 ''% G +, 5")//01%8  %   '%   '    '% ' $  %$ '%  ++ 5' )//.#87 '%''%J'' 7%% %' )+J')//0 8''% G +, 5")//01 6'#' 5' 7% %'7'5' %1

  '%' ( '% ' %5'8 %' '%7 ' E+G#4 '%$87 'E)G7  5'1# 7 'E,'+ G '6'4%$#6'   25% '6 6872'' '% '#7$'  45'1

  ''#%6%55 87 'A/G#'% ' 6'   ' L &' %' '%% '1

  :7&'    & 5 '# 7 ' E/ ' +    G  7'2'   9 % 2# $  F% &'%# ' 7 '   %'"  ' 27  '  7'55"  $'    35 7' '%   %'1  7&''   5'4 7 '55" 8 & 5'4     7 ' ) ' )  G1

  74 '#    27  '   $  F% &'%   J278 IG.//1(5)# ' P5'6 5  'Q1

+A1   %'''%.%$5")//0# '"%%# ' '%  7 ' A+   %'   % 5''  '$  +) 5"+D-0; ( 0+/=#7:11#!1!  !1:$%'1

+-1   % +E%$5")//0#!1 3% %% ''%  '6' '$  ++ % %" )//0 9  '" 5''  '61  %  "5  8  J% '%    %$ % K &'  % *./0)*)//0 K $   *,-,.*)//0# 7&'  7 5L5 %54  6' 1  6%# '  '  %'%    J%   % 6%'  $'% '%7 'E.G1

*,-,.*)//0 (E*+,(

+D1  )5")//0# G ' %'%1

  7 ' %5  %  %' 5 '%% 65'$ 7 '.AG1

  % '%' ( '%#('7$' 8L  %'   %55''%1  3'66    74 '   $'6'   %55''%6''   "'%' 2'7 ' %5%% 0/N7 '&'%1

  '4'55"&'% '%7 ' 6' # '454'55'' %"'&'%   IG-1(*5)1

    265'#!1 3% 7$' 2' %%'%  ''%J '5 1

   87 %' '%'$''%'%#!1 3% ' O %'% ''%$'+/%O )//01

  6'# 7     ' 8  %# !1 3%  7$'   8 L  %$%2 % EJ')//01

)/1   +, 5" )//0# !1 !    :1 %  6'  $'  %"$ '% %   4 %1  %  % "5  8  J% '% #6%#8%6'5 '%''% 2#$ ' 6' 1

  '%' ( '%:11%5'!'&7 '  %5' 8  %' '%#  :11 7    %' ' 7 '6  '5  &'%1

  7 ' 8J  ' 2 G $' %%J '5  >+-+E1 66 #% '"6#'?$' ' '%5  7 ' 9 "J '6# 8 $%' 7 '' '% 66 '$    %& 1 ''# 766  '% "J '$  3C   !'& 2'  '  L  %' %55 &'%# $'  75%    %   %"J '6 2# 7 6H%&# % 6 '%$   ' %8 1

  6'# ' 7? $'   '   3  7' '%  7 ' E. G# & J '5 6' ' %$ 2 '% '$44 '%''74%'  '% 8 ' %1

)+1   )) 5" )//0# !1  :$%'  6'      %"$ '%  %1

   '  % 86'  &' '&%% !1 3% 8:11

*,-,.*)//0 (A*+,(

  ?  %J%  "%% $%''&$!1 3%   '  2'     %6'%'5   '# ' 7$'  J5'  7'  '%5 ''"'&'%1

   8%'"'' %65'74%' 5 '%# ' 7 % '  8  J '#  '  5%' 2# %5     '%27'  ' $!1 3% #''  ' % 53% 5 8'%'$8%& 574%'  '%%5'1

  6'#    2  '   '5%'   %55     %#  %5'!'&$' L % &1  &#!1 3% $' #' %5"# ''8$& '5%'1

))1  .J$')//E# '"5''  '6%%J% '% *,-,.*)//0  *./0)*)//0%5% *,-,.*)//01

),1   )E J$' )//E#  J& &      '  '  %5 '%%1

  !1 3% %6'5 5%%1"'865% ' '  ' '7$' % '':11 %5  '  9'  $'  P"%'  %' &Q1  % '   7 '  %5' &'%   8:11>+.0A$' 3 $&'%1 (' $'  % '5 8'& "'1

   5'5  '  3&'  ' 8  $ &'%#  %$  > +-+E ?   5L5  ' '2 2   >+.0A1

   %$ %& $'  % 66   % '   '  6 2'% ' 6%'17&'' ''9 '"%' >+.0A 1

  %3' ' 4%%' 5 '%&'%  $' 5%?17 '  ' 872'' '%P 3C Q1

  74 '  5 )//0 % ' '   " '   7&'   7$ '% &'%1 '&'%&%'' 8 IG.#0/ 59 1

   G '2'454'55'' 7$' 8 IG-1(59  1

  !1 !  ''2 2  :11 7$'   %J  %    ' &'%  %5'1   '  $ 2 !1 3% # 8   ' # ' 2'

*,-,.*)//0 (-*+,(

 ' '%'(5L51:6'' %$'&'  '%5'17?' %%  "'8651

  !1 3%   ' $%' 6'    8 !1 !  % %3'  2  8 72'' '%7 ' '&'%%5'!'&1'$'  %J%' 27'4' %%' 5 '%1

  %$%&7 ' % '%''1 7$% '%  %    "'# % $  ''%    %'"''   5 74%'  '%8% 6'7' ' "'1 ''#%%' '% !1!  85 6'65&%5 '$'  '7 '  '6' 1

  !1 !  %   $%'   ''%  J   %'   5 '%1   ' 2  :11 7$'   7'  '%  '$' %  5%%%5' '$$ '1

  !1 3% '$%'%  ''%$' %'   '$''% '# %'   ''%  +/ %O  )//0# 6   ' $%'   % '6'17$' '%'2%%' '%$  G  +, 5")//01

  :7&'   74 '  5 )//0#  G   ' 2  6'  27' 7&'' 74 ''$7$' %66 '$"1 %55''% $'  66'55   ''  % %$%'  5' '  3'66 '4 '%%' 8' 531

  :% !1 3% #   4 ' $'    5 % J '6'  '4 ?   % "% ' 8  %'% 2    &'%  '  '  '6'8 %&'%1

  !1 !  ' 27'  7&''      4 ' 6'  8 %%   $  %5'1 %     "% ''  8  5L5 %'%1

  :%!1 3% #' ' %5%' % 27$'%3  2 (3' 2%5 ' %5'5 ' % '7 ''( '&' '%%' 6%'1

   G   ''2 2# %27' 7&''   $%'  #   '2 ' 75 %66'' /#) '4F%8"C '% ' % "C '5 %&'%' F%&'%1

  !1 3% 6' $%'2%%' ' % '7 '%5' &'%357' '%%' 6%'1

*,-,.*)//0 (D*+,(

  :11'2D0N%5'5' J '%' 6%' 1

  :2%'# &8J&1

) 

+1   J  5 '#4%% $"%' $ ; 1 -- G@  1 0E    %'  B%&' '% J'''  )) %$5" +D.+@( )/0@ 1+,%'7' '%%'6%'  6%'@ G(!++/=1

)1   %  %    5' '  $''    '%  ' (  '%%   G %%% %')+J')//01

,1   ' '   ''% ' '&'# !1 3%    2'  % %' ; 1E/ 1 =1

.1  72'' '% 7  ' % 7 '55" &'%   %5' 8  %' '%; 1E+1+G=17', '%' '%'2%   2'' '%#  6   %' # '' 2 %      J''2 2'$ %%5'25 8 6 %' 1

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

*,-,.*)//0 (+/*+,(

01 1  G      %'  5''  '$  %%5  5'9 '    %   %&  $'   B'  '% B  %'  5''  '$@  %'  L  %' %55   %'  5''  '$     ' + ') 0 & ; *,E-*+DDD+0J'+DDD=19&%""0! B'2 %8'''% G ; 1+1+ =1

  B %'  "' 6' B%66'@B '5' &  %66$ '; 1+D =1

 "1  G %5%K%7 ')'+9&5 74 '%  %' 7' '%   %' 6   %'  6%'  ;! + +/1/+= (  %'    7 &'9$# %' '% 6R '9  7&'  &$%'# 7      35"  % '# 7      35" &$%' '55%"''9# 7     %5   %' '  "''55%"''4 7  "&$%'1G%5%  ''' #%55''% ''4% M 3'2 2 '"5''  '61

  79#%74 '5'8 G #$"'  :11 '8 IG+,B0//B///1(%2$$ '68 $% '% &'%    IG 0B0//B///1(  %  2  "'   %' ' %5%%0/N7 '&'%1 G #  %  8  %      8  %5 '% %#  66  %   5 7'  '%  '1  6' #    $'6' ' % %72 '%3'66 74 '$'  '1 74 '  % 6'  7%"J  7 45 5' '4   %55''% 2'  $  J   '4  1 %   #  %  79&  5   '  2' ' 5    74 '  )//0  %  27'%%"J '$5 7 1

    '% # 7  8 "% %'  2  G   %   2  '%  ' ( '% 7 '   %5' 8  %' '%1  ''%  '%2 %6'51

  7' 2#% '5 82% ' % # 'E)  '$ G7% 8L 45'1

E   %  %   &5  7% %' 7  %' '% 4 '% %  &5 ' '&'%1

A1   %$'  745' '  '"     "' %5   % %R ' '&#'('45' 7%66'%5 1

 1  5  7 ' E. ' )  #  %  8   %'  '%5     5' 7%66' 8  J'' '% 5''  '$ %5  1 7   %8 82' 85'9 %' 1

*,-,.*)//0 (++*+,(

 "1 :%B 'A', G#5%5 7'55"'  F% &'% ?  6'  7%"J  7 5'5  '   %5' 4 ' '%7 '-D%'5'% '%6%'9; !(!+ /0=1  '%' '%'2%$7 %' '% 5 #  5%5   ' &'% 5'   ' '   '5'    5   2 2 %'   6   8 1  ''%   5   '"%8%55''% 5'% '% 6%'9; 1D) !=1

   79#  $'   %' 7% '%  '$''% '%  1

     2'92%%!1 3% %' L  5' 8  %55''%    5'% '% 6%'9 % '%  %5 1

  %%'$"%' 1

-1  $2'9#''% G +, 5")//0  ++% %")//0% #''%$'7  6'' '$ % 2% '%% 7 %' ' '5 5 1

D1  !1  :$%' %" '  &'   7&'    ''%  )+ J' )//0#''%2'%1 5%5 5'83&  7?   %  %'%   #  '5'   '  %1

  5%5  IG0//1(5'83&:112'7%" '  2 '5 &'1'5' %# IG+B///1( %8!1 3% 83&%' 1

   5%5    5' 8  3&  !1 !# % %5 ''%)+J')//01

   5%5   IG 0//1(  '6'& 8 !1 3%  2' %" '   '5  &'  1  '5'   %#  IG0//1(  %83&8!1!''27'5' 5L55%  8 :11

   5%5   IG 0//1(  5' 8  3&   G  %  4 ''%% 1'5' %# IG0//1(%8 !1 3% 83&7  9$1 SSSSS

*,-,.*)//0 (+)*+,(

2' )         

304#/"5

 '$"  % ' J   ,+ % %" )//0  !%' (2 3% % ''%%55''%6%'9&'%+, 5")//0  27'$'''%$'7&' +/%O )//0@

$"%6

415

J   27'$'''%%   '%)+J')//0@

75   27'% ''%+, 5" ++% %")//0@

''%+, 5" ++% %")//0@

$%'  %' 8  %55''% 6%'9 &'% % %$ ''% 9 %'  J&%55''% 5'% '%6%'9@

5   % 8  %55''%    5'% '% 6%'9    27' % ''%$'7&' +/%O )//0@

5 83&% 5%5  IG0//1(@

5  8  3&   %'  '55%"''9  %5'  !'&  5%5   IG0//1(@

5 83&%55''%6%'9&'%5%5  IG0//1(@

%'5' %  IG+B///1(83&%' '55%"''9 %5'!'&  IG0//1(83&7  9$@

%'5'  IG0//1(8%' '55%"''9%5'!'&  '5' 5L55%  8!%'GH%'!#83&% @

'  2# %6%55  4  ' DA   '$    %' 6 B%&' '% J'''# L  L % #$%'%%' 5''  '6#    J% 9  % '6' '%# ($   '" 6@  55%'  %%' ''2%'%#5% '6 5%?$ % '&  % %%5 '@'%' L  %'45'5%' '" 6# +///  +.@    L     '9  %'%  % #'$%2%555%?$#%'$ L J%' 8B$%'@

*,-,.*)//0 (+,*+,(

%55'2    L  8 !  "# $%   % # 8 ! ''  '# $%   !%' ' %( 55  :$%'# 8 ! % !&$# $%   !%' GH%' !     %'  '55%"''9  %5'  !'&##''2B8%55''%6%'9&'%#8B%66'6 J ' 8%55''% 5'% '%6%'91

:'& < !5%$?#' #!1?39#!5I'#!1 3'#!5%# J&1

%5 '"5''  '6<

&66'9(J' J1<  $'(' <     !1 %%' 1%$?  

%'%6%5 L  %55'24 '1

 9$#  &66'9<           

*,-,.*)//0