Statutory Penalty for Refusal to Assist Tax Investigation
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertThe case involves an appeal concerning the proper interpretation of a statute imposing a penalty on persons who refuse to provide assistance during an investigation into potential tax evasion by a third party. The court reasoned that the statute's language, which mandates assistance to an authorized agent, unambiguously applies to the refusal to respond to an administrative summons demanding documents, not merely to physical obstruction, thereby upholding the imposition of the statutory penalty against the non-compliant party.
Legislator-Regeste
AmtlichARBRE; POUVOIR D'APPRÉCIATION; PESÉE DES INTÉRÊTS; EXPERTISE; AUTORISATION DE DÉFRICHER | Refus d'autoriser l'abattage de 5 arbres tricentenaires qui, selon une expertise privée produite par le département, pourraient être conservés encore quelques dizaines d'années si des mesures d'élagage et d'haubanage étaient réalisées. Les arguments d'ordre esthétique et historique, liés à l'appartenance de ce "bouquet" d'arbres à un parc planté au XVIIIème siècle, entièrement replanté ces dernières années en conservant le plan d'origine, ont été pris en compte par le département dans la pesée d'intérêts qu'il a été amené à faire. Doit également être pris en compte, la protection accrue des arbres, sis dans la zone de protection des rives du lac, découlant de la LPGRL. In casu le département n'a pas mésusé de son pouvoir d'appréciation. | LPGRL.1; LPGRL.11; RCVA.1; RCVA.11
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertCited in the final order concerning the allocation of procedural costs.
Cited in the final order concerning the granting of legal aid.
Volltext
!"!# !$%& !""#$% % '$ && & % & (%%( %&& &(% & ) && (% ( %
&'()*&
&
). !/ " %/ %" " ))-0 %// 1% 2 3 )4# % 5&& 1%. " 23" ""/6 % "%" " %"% "% 7"$8/9)44':&8),;.
%" 3 #<#=>31/"%" % <%/56# "$/ #> %"78) /%" "# 23%"7" /""#9 ?6/ "6#%%.
%#=" /"%&%" 5> 2 3"6>5" 9%> <%/ @9%> "$@#% " 7/ 39 %" $%"" 9% 1/" %".
'. " / ',,8# 3" %" 3%" % # 39 7"9A %"9.
*. >B +="',,8#$"<%B #% "% A7 / 3" "# 37" 3$"%/ # $ " % %/" A7 :"&6 C ; / " %" :"&6 C ;# !%" " %/ # %5%" "#%"" 39 79<%/ 3"71 #3%" @9%> <% "$@.
8. %//""%/%/ # " :"&6C !D; $" <$%9/ >B % %" %$ "% 9%> .
0. '4 % %9 ',,8# %" 39 7 %" "7 /%" "% " 3"71/"<# A%/"3%" % @9%> <% "$@ 2 %" "% > %" %""7 "5/B/// "" ".
/B/=%# ""%<% 39 7 9 <%/ 9%> . /"< " " % 1" %"> $%%7">: %/%<#$"<# .;. "%/ " %$ "> /= % >> "E" 3 % ="2% " "%3/9#2%7 /. % <%"# " 9 75 % 7B %$ "% %" B 9 # %$$"%/ .
(++,(',,- &*()*&
-. F=" ',,0#!/%/ %9 3 %" "%39 " 99%> 2%" "%<%"%= "%.
+. /B/ =%# !. %/ >" 39 7 0 9 @9%> <% "$@" 59%1/"%". 9 " > " " <% / " %" . 91 " /G" " .91)8/%7 0,/"/6 3 " "%>%" .>B " <" % 2/"$"1/"%".
F. '-%H ',,0# #%" %"<3 %" "%39 0 " /%". 9 " 7 % 3" . % <%" 7 77 197 $" B " "%%//"" "79.
4. -% %9',,0#!.%/ %6%//""% % %/ "6% "%:"&6C ! ;% ""% '-%H ',,0#5"0 /9 G)* /9',,0.
""% " 9" " "<%. 3" " "%39 7$" B $.
$" /%>@%$ 9%> %% "5 %""6 >/" "%>>"3$ 09<<> %"<%% " ="923%$ %@.
" >"E # /7 $" "7% " %"75#9 " %/91>%" 7% 91" //%//$ ."> " "/" 9 =%5 " 1/. % # 37" 9 " 9% 1/" %"# 7 % "$" " . % 3 9 91 3 %/9" 1/" /G" 9I "/ $%"".
%& "/" 7 %" 9 9%> . 639 77 "9%> #09"%#" " 39 7# " 5% " <% 5 $ 7 9 9%> % 7" . 3=% " >%/%" "% %# 7"#3$" /"3"/ %<%9 >"">" <" 3B ".
3 " 2 % >$" "$%>3" B 1" %">/" " 9. $ 1" %"> " %" 2 2 /9 %/% 9%> . " /%" "% 75
(++,(',,- &8()*&
3 %>. % " " $ 2 % " "% 1" %"> " . 31%/%7" 9%> " % %""6.
5" " %/95$"59#% /%"#%9" <# $"%. " "= "<" / 7 %/%/ %$ "%3" 1" %">%%$9" /%" 23 %/%< 23$"<.
),. '8%$/9',,0#23"3"%/ "%% "# /"2 ! 5 "" "$"5 /%" %# << 3 " 9%" &%" D2 !%7# "$% // % %%7".35 % " 7 1 "6%7'0/"<%1 "".3931 *-/ 3"%<*00/#$" B " /" 19 % 8 % ' "$5 "% %% 5 2 %" /6 . 1%" $" B /" "7"62F&),//5"// % J 7 1%76 " '&* . %/%71" % "">" "%5 "<</""/% .
5 " %//">2!.%/ 4/9',,0. %" %9$ "%2 ! )*=$"',,-.
% "">" >3" A $" "/% 7 /%" >3" $" B ". 3 " 77 <" "/% %3197 /%"39." <" "/<".
)). '* =$" ',,-# ! = % !. %/ . " %" 63"'8%$/9',,0$" "" B "%/ /"$3"" "7#> "% " "%$ .
="" "% /"" "$ 3$" %/ % " 3%% " 3 ""%. ""% 3 " " 9" " " % " "$ 3 56%$%"3" "%">3 " <%/ %9= "< % % 35 ""$% " %"%. %$ B = 37" 39%9/ ">#"$" B /B/ <% "%" % 9 %. /% "< "< 2 3 1 ">="$" 3%% " .
)'. D" 2>B %'<$"',,-# %"#),<$" ',,-#377/%"%35 "3 " 9%" &%" D2.
)*. % ' / ',,-# %5 %/ % % 6 "9 /"" "< % ""% ! % "<" *) =$" ',,-.
(++,(',,- &0()*&
% #$" <" #23 "%""% ! 2 "$ 3 %" "% 39 7 % / F =" ',,0 # 9"""/ # $%" 2 ! % %// 3" "% # 9"""/ %# 2 >3 5 " %" %% %<"2"" 1% %.
3" "% ! 3$" %>39. / %/%71"$" << 9 %/%" >" " 3 /"6 7 " /%" " . # ! 3$" " " % " 3%9= " "7.
""%$"%" %" 3B . 3$" 35"/ " % 35 "#"/%"#"%H & ".
%" 1/" %"# % " 9" " " 3/9# $" 9/ $"" >" 3$" 2 "%" "%> $%"" "%.%"$%A" "$"//" 3 %" "% 39 7 % 377 " 9 " 7 "//" %%%9"" %. <" " " 9 <" $"%%%""1%.91 F/%7 00/"/6 3 " 9 1/"%"*, % %9',,0.$" <" 79/"7 " . %"3$" %9 /" " <" 752>>/6 3$%"" "%.
""%$"%" ""%% "%" 5%" 2 <" "%". D% $" >3" $" >"# / %" $"" 2 KL83-,,.& % > 39 7 %H " KL'3F0,.&. D% 3$"!/!"%7 3 "31% " A7"/ .%7 7"#A %2377/%""">32 % $5 "% %/"# @" "% 9 " %"9# /" $" "<<"" %H :197# %%" "%# " / %" #% J7"# .;# 7 "% 7 " / % 9 %/9 %/" 9"# " %"/ "9$".
)8. %" G 8 $" ',,- "9 /"" "<# %5 %/ % ""> >3 /%" 9%> # " %" $%""# 3 J 1/" %"# " %/9 ) $" ',,-# 39 % $ . 9 % " /" "% $" "/ 2/B/%>.37"" %""6/9 %E/%">"" #>"%$" 7%" 9% "$"% .
(++,(',,- &-()*&
)0. + $" ',,-# %5 %/ % /" "9 /"" "< %" 3 %" 0 $" ',,- /""% / 3 M%N" 63<<" "%".L" " 21 /%"#/""%/ "" $"%9%$ "% 9 9" $%%" / "% " <" 3$" 7I / " %%%3$".
)-. ),$"',,-# %%% 2%= .
$9"" % " % !.%/ " " " ""% ! ">3" $" 7" %# % >""% " 2!/%/ #%" ".
%" 3B %5%/ 3$" $"%"> "9 /"" "< %$" # 1 # $"% "%. /B/# 3" "%%$" B %/ #"".
> 67/ %$ "% $7 "% 9%'+% %9)444: &8,0.,8;$" %9 %$ "% $7 .
1 91 % 39 % "/ %" 9 % " < 39 7. " $" %=% % " % "% /= $" "" 39 739%"%//75$" %".39 73 9 %/9$" 3" %"/"%%<< .
1/" %"# 9" > $ " $ <>// $"" # 3 " % <%" 6 %//G # " >"%/#"9".35" " ">E%/ "6.
D" / 1"> / " "/" "> 1 91%39I76*,, <%/ / /= A7#" " %<%/9 >%$ "% 9%" "/%#9"&<%/%"A %O %<"/35 "3 """.
$" 17 %H " 5 $5 " "%=>323"" "7.
$ "%9% " <%$" <" 3%9= 3 7%" "% $ . << !D $" 1 %= "% $ " ". % "% % " %$/ $7 "% %$ "% "/%"9% 5" 3" " ""% ". %" "% "% " % <"5 6 /"6 " 3 "
(++,(',,- &+()*&
"%% "%3"/%"17<"3197 377# $ "5 3/9 %= . %H <%" "% 3 9%$" B "/ KL)3,,,.& KL)30,,.&.
/" "9 /"" "< %= "% #9%3 ".%7 %H ',,8#>""">" % // > %$ "% 9%> /" " 3B 3" %<"/" > /=%" 7 9 %$" B %$ 1/ 5"<. /"< @% " " %"% " " 2 7 "$=".3 " 7B 2 7>3"<< " 5" /9 9%"5>"/6 @.
)+. )' $" ',,-# %5 %/ % <" $" "9 /"" "< %" 3 %" + $" ',,- /""% / 6 "% " 37" "% !%" %//. /""% "7" > 9 %" !. %/ # $%"" " %<<"" 3/9 " 7<" I7 %" "%." $" B <" %>3"%" 9 /"".
)F. )* $" ',,-# %5 %/ "<%/" "9 /"" "< > 39 >" 3 " // %" $%""# 2 !%" "PL"/"1#$" "3 <"%$%"B 5/" "9%3 % .
)4. ),/"',,-#<" $" "9/"" "<%" %2/""%/ .39% 1 $" " )$"',,-%$" B "/"59$%"". " % %% 9%" $" <" 3%9= "$ %" "% 39 7 % 9 " # 9 % ',,0 ',,-. 1> 9 $" <"3%9= 3A"<"> "$" 21>%" "3<< $5 " 2 3 " 9# % $ 3 %" "% "$.
',. )'/"',,-#=7723" "% % 2 % " !/ " L"/"1# % /" !. "P L"/"1# !%" "% 7" 3 " 9%" &%"# !/ !" %7 # =""6& A7" #!%"%/">#/%A!/%7 .
%"%#" % >/%"$" "/"% % 19. %5 %/ % ""> > 197 >" / " <%1/"%"/" << J <% $ #393 % 7 ">"5" " // >"$" /= ".
(++,(',,- &F()*&
!.>"> % 91/%">3"$" 7 " . 3$" % % " 91 ".197 >%%%%" 2>3"$" " ">"&"$" B <" /"6 "7".
!.7" !/%7 % " % "%=2<" .
D%!.%/ #/" "9%> /B1" % "% >""9" %= 1" "%.
!%""%K#%97 "% "/%"9% "">>3" " % 2<" %"9 93 " "/6 /B/ " %H " "<< . %5 %/ % % > "39"/% " 1%3$"""" .
'). D>%"# "% "<%/> " 72=7.
''. '' /" ',,-# %5 %/ % "<%/ "9 /"" "< >3"/% 9139% /%"/%"" "7"5/" "9% " %/9. " $"" "5.
'*. * =" ',,-# %5 %/ % "<%/ "9 /"" "< >39" $%"" " %/9 $1/" %". " %12<%1@/%"@.39$" "/6 1 "/6 *+/.
& %
). = / " $ ="" "% %/ # % $9: .0- %"3%7" "%="""''%$/9)48)& & ',0Q .-*.)" .%"%/"" "$)' /9)4F0& & 0),;.
'. / % >" %7"!.%/ $ ! .
. " $ <" %=%" : . 4 . ) ;. D/# %" = "<"%$%"% "%" : .4.' ;.
!. %/ >" 3 %" "% 39 7 " "7"# % % 3A % "7 > %" ". !/ %/ " " ""% /" 3 !. %/ >" "7 % % < 3 %" "% " = 6 ! " <%// >3" 7"" > %%. ! % "<"""%2
(++,(',,- &4()*&
!.%/ %5% <"/ %%=%" / 6 "9 .
! " <" $<%/"/5"<"$" " >" %7"2!.%/ .< / >3"$9/ % %# %" " 9 % ""% # 6 ! .
9. 3"" "7#> "%35" 3" B % " !.%/ 23 "%""% ! # >$3 "-, 9 # %$ #%%A "9" 9/ >" % %".
*. % <% 7"< 2 ! 3$%" $"% %" 3B / %% $9/ % 35 "/" 3A " " %/6 / %". %% 7/ "9<"%2 5 ".
. >R" 7 "R "'4"' % " "%<)F $" )444 : . & D ),);# %" RB %/ %" % " <" $%" %" $ $ >R ""% %" "# <%" $ > 5 <" 2 "< ""%# R$%" 6 %"# "" 2 R/"" "% $# R %" /" 2 %% : B "9 < '.++(',,*4=" ',,*%".'.) B " Q ()+'(',,8' / ',,8 B " ;. %/ 7/ %" 3%9 " >3" %" %" 5%<<$ " : L)'484+#%".'.' < " ;. =7 < / %9 %" >3" %"6 >3 " 2 % $ % %> $ /"" " % /" <%/ %$" "% ># % 3 /"6%9" "2" "% ""$>""% % %%#" " >3%" 3/2/%"<"%%""% : L',,0*+0#%".'.'Q L)*,8'0#%".'.);.$/B/ %><" 2 9" =2% "%% %": L ',,0*4+#%".8.;.
9. ""% " % $"% "% %" RB R # /" 9 : B "9 < '.',+(',,) )' %$/9 ',,)%".0 B " ;. % <%"#$"% "%%" RB 9 $ R" % " &" =%" /B/ %$%" R5/ > "% " "7" > R %" " "/ " R5/ > "% 6$ R%% " # R %" % % 9 " %%$%"R5/2"R %" /"6" : B "9 < '.*,(',,* ' =" ',,* %". '.8 B " Q (+*(',,0 )0 <$" ',,0 Q (+,*(',,' )4 %$/9 ',,'Q
(++,(',,- &),()*&
(-,4(',,) ' % %9 ',,)Q . !# %" /"" "<C /"" "< % J#$%.#)44)#1.'.'.+.8.)4,;.
R6# " " " /" " %" RB % $"% ! . << # "% 35"/ " % %" /" % 35/ " "7 "9 % 2 % . ""# $ $"% "% %" RB % .
D37" 35 "/#<"7 %"#%<" 2 " "" " # 9 3%9$ "%%/6 . ""% / % %9"& <% %// 3" "%3$6"""36.
8. % %1 2 ! /%O 7 > 9"$"7" %$ "%# ""37" /%"./%$ "%" "%% "%.
. % 9 % 7 " "$" " > ">"">E%"9$%"": .);.
9 # 7" $ > 37" <%"%# $7 5" $" B $7#$%"/B/ %$" : .));.
9. % 9 3 %$ "%# 2 $%" % "%# /" " %$/ $7 "% <%/ / /= A7: .) ;.
K% <%B # 9 B 9 % 7 %" "% 9 : . *- %" % "% /%/ # " 8=")4+-&!D&8,0Q .* ;.
/ "$"//" / %" "%39 7% 377 %>3" % # "&/B/# $" %" " % 3 "# >3 9 7 "//" % % % 9" " %: .)) ;.
9 " "7"5 9<"" 3 % "% "% %" "%%1"$.
. % B <%/ % $"% "% %" A %/" 356 39 %$%" 3" "% : . -) . ' ;. ="" "% /"" "$ 3% %/ % " 3%% " ""% ># < 5 "% $ %" : . -) . ' ; % " 36.
(++,(',,- &))()*&
. =7 %" $"<" " 3/"" "% 3 9 % %$%" 3" "%. # "" %% "%" /=.#"""/%" B /"" % % / : . # " B $ =7 /"" "< " 7%9 " B # %" 3$"%/ 3/7/ " %"#)44-#.)F4 #% // )4'()4*;.
. 3 %" ="""5"9%$%"% J%>33 "/ 2 1%"#3 &2&"%>3" "% %/ <" 2 %" "" % ""6. $1#%>= %"5"7"" "%3 1"" 7# "9 3"/% " # %//""% % %/% % "" : (0-,(',,8 ''=" ',,8;./B/# "9" 3 /% "< 3" "% 37" > "% 1"> : (8+(',,0 ) <$" ',,0Q L. S K # %$%" 35/ %$%" ""% "9 /"" "<# L',,,#.08* <" ;.
0. 36# ! 3 9 " %" "%2 >" "/>9#% 39 7 " >"#% " " / /= A7 " 7 <<" % 3" . "%$" / #">/=#%$ %>>"E"3.
%" $ %<% 5 " " 2 / # 9 "" " # >" %"" 7/ / %$ "%# %" 197 77# 37" 7 /%".
% %% 2 5 "3$"1" A7" # "/ >" "%9 %"9/"$" "<<"" %H # 7 " % 7 " / % 9 %/9 %/"9".
% $ 7/ 7/ "2$ "% 3 1 "> 2 >" 1" %"> 3/9# > /%"31" A76?6/"6.%= "% =25 % "$ "/ %%/">"/% . % 7/ % <" / 7" "/ %"$ B " %/ 3" B <" 3/"" "%. % <%"# %= "" " "% "" %$ "% 9%> >"# 3$" 31" A7/ % #%$" <" / 3" 7 23/9 .
(++,(',,- &)'()*&
$/ % %9$ >"3"/%<2 > "% "/"> %" "" 37/ $ 3%% " ""%#"O >3/%%$%" 3" "% "$"7" %$ "% 9 %/7 /% "%.$"""#% #%2 " B >" %$" #"3 <%/ %9= "< %% / > # 3 "5 >" B >"<" 3"%"# 37" 3 "<< 3$"% KL )3+,,.& $ "5 39 7#/ %$9%""E"3.
% # % "/ 2 > % " % # " 3""> > 3" " %/ "$ "" " 2 9 % /%" /%"# " $%""7# "" >" " % 7"6/ "7.
-. %>#%= .
/%/ KL )R80-.&# %/ KL 80,.& 5 /%" KL -.& <"# /" 2 17 % " %=%" / %""/ : .F+ ;.
3"" "7#"%3"/" .
TTTTT
$ (&% &
*+" ,
$9 % " = * / ',,- !/ " !%""%/ % ""%%//""% %% / "6% "%'*=$"',,-Q
+"!,
= Q
/ 2 17 % " %=%" / %""/ /%/ KL)R80-.&Q
%//"> B 2!""#$% % # / " %""">R2%//""% %%/ "6% "%.
(++,(',,- &)*()*&
D"7 C !/%$A#" #!.A16#!/K"#!. 1"#!/%# =7.
%/ "9/"" "<C
7<<"6&=" =.C $"&" C !. %%" .%$A
%"%<%/ B %//">5 ".
6$# 7<<"6C
(++,(',,-