Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATA/317/2005 • CJ GE ATA/317/2005 KI-generiert

Administrative Fee Assessment Challenge Upheld on Due Process Grounds

Geschäftsnummer ATA/317/2005
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Abgewiesen (Dismissed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The appellant challenged an assessment regarding an administrative fee, arguing the fee structure was unduly retroactive and vague, thereby violating due process by failing to provide clear notice of the obligation. The court held that the administrative fee statute, as applied, was sufficiently clear and provided adequate notice through regulatory guidance and historical practice, even if the statute itself was broad, thus affirming the assessment because the application was not shown to be impermissibly retroactive or so vague as to prevent compliance.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Administrative Fee Assessment Challenge Upheld on Due Process Grounds: The court held that the administrative fee statute, as applied, was sufficiently clear and provided adequate notice through regulatory guidance and historical practice, even if the statute itself was broad, thus affirming the assessment because the application was not shown to be impermissibly retroactive or so vague as to prevent compliance.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Verwaltungsgebühr Zulässige Gründe Honorarfestsetzung Gesuch an eine Behörde Festsetzung der Busse Vorherige Verwaltungsbeschwerde

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision governs the allocation of court costs, as explicitly ordered in the final dispositive.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

        

        

  

    

 !

"#$%$&' ()





()% $  !  "#$%&" 

" 

+ , ++ -- ++ + ,. - 





     '()*'

+ 

./  !"#  000000000%   .1*2% "3### 000000000% .(,* 4&%   # #53#"#"&6#73" #&74& 2," "8.19+/

(/  :"""#; "3"8## "# &# "3"8#    &#< #" =#'4> : ?%  "        3 #4  # #"" #4%7&"# # 3##@3"#""*A&# .11-"&"#"#   ;8# /

2/  (1"&38(,,+7.B6*,%;# ## &"# ;&  63%# #"!#6':& %"C;#; 3 ;"  #"#  7  # " D7 <<   <  # /  # "  6    6   ;  &  #'3E3/     <43  8/

+/  &#    :  7 "#  "8& #"% !/ 000000000 ;  "  A# C## # "6/#&"C8"#"A#" #";&6#73" /@F# "A#"3G& #&#  A"#A#3 &"&6# "# &#; #  # #C "   "<  ;/  &#  8"# C" ##3   " &6#/

*/  ##".+D&#(,,*%: ? #3#"# !/000000000 C 3"#%# #"5 #.B#2     "# A   # #" " #4  .1 38 .1*- =  ' :9+./,.?/  :     C ;#   D #A##    8"# "A#" ;     C    #" ; "3"8##  ; #   8" "3  H  3"#A&#.11-;  / "3   ;38  #" % ; "#  ""F#   3 C# ; #   3##33</

B/  !/000000000## #83##  #A; ""  ##"# % (2A&#(,,*/;"  A# C##  # "6%3##@#CC;#"# &"#<6;&  63%"CA#"#   #  ""/ #&# &6#7 CC#@34 # /&# &" " "  #"7# #"% 3# # ;&#   &  # " <<   <%    # "#    6%C## # 3C&6# "& 7"# ;   3"  7#C&# E  #&#/

  " 7 #" # 7@3"#/

)+,-)(,,* '2)*'

9/     #  "3 #" "  (, &# (,,*% !/000000000# @# #" "#"/

  : # ##" #%"#< C;#A## &  &#  "C  #   # "%  "I  <<   < " <% # D/

-/   #4"#C!/000000000""3# "#3#: +3(,,*/

+ - 

./   D   3  # &   D## #" "3  %  "   &8= /*B "#5"<# #"D###(("&38.1+.' ' (,*J /B2/. //"#"3##  #&.(  38.1-*' ' *.,?/

(/   # #"  "3  "#  # "# <#   A"3    =(,,(%/(9B9J" /(9-.?% #  <#4<&#< 3"3 ;#A #"/

2/ " A## @# " &6= /22/.  ?/

  & <"# "%" #&  ##4  %  8"#% 5E  " #  #"#  @ # " C#  "& D7<"5K<< = /22/( ?/

+/   &"#    ##4 #3" @  "3"8##  75"6 5 < " # "    3   #   #  "AA    </ : &#" #" " #  ##  A  5 <&#   # = )*-()(,,+  B D#  (,,+   A/ # /?/    5 # B  5""4<# #"" #4.2"&38.1B(= ' :9+./..?%&#<#.D#.11+%A""&"# "   "3"8## #"# @<" C# 7#/

*/   #   &"    &"#    #"  #  #'

%  "   &#"  #"# #" # / : A   #  E  3"##"# #"# #" C## ;E  "&/  #  #   AA  ;E  ;    &#<#  7 ;"6  <  # C# #" #  C"I #;&# 8" &##8##    "# %    C 3E3  "3" 3  #C   "# E "67; "3"8## C### " 3  &"#'7/  #83##  #A"#4"C5 78""# C:  A"3# #<#5 #.B#2 /

)+,-)(,,* '+)*'

B/      #    A#@ "  #" /    5 3"#  3##33= /.9/ / ?/

  #& A  "#&  E  #  "# #"% " 33   <&#  "8D #&   8D #&   A %      5#  ## C  8"# "A#" = / 22 / (  J L .,- 8 (*1J / ::M)/ : % "## #"" #4%"33 #%.11B%/(.-J!/  %#&  # 3#"#%.1-(%/.--?/  @3%  "C  5#A #" "33#  #  &"#  #A ##& = L .19- / (--?/  %   5  #     #85E A#@'73##33<%3E3"C5#  8"  = L.1-./*,?/

  "C5 #  &#  &  # " <<   <  # 7# 3 5&"# E & <% 68# 3 #A#<&#C 7#@3"#"8"#"A#"  538#" = )B2()(,,+*"N (,,+ A # ?/

9/   4%: "" # 5C  3"#%C# # "3 7A"#A "33#OC#3 ;  "  '##C;88"#"A#"#"5 3#"#/

   "C%  ##"  5 "# %  " "#  "A"3 7  D#%# E # #C "A#3/

-/  ""D /

   ;#  # #<%  3"3   $L 2,,/'  3# 7  6<  " %C#"38= /-9 ?/ PPPPP

/  +- 0 +    

1!2(#$3

 &8  " # D   (2 A&# (,,*  !"#  000000000 " ##"&# "3"8# &#< #".+D&#(,,*#  # "3#"#"C 3"#J



)+,-)(,,* '*)*'

2()3

D J

3 76<" 3"3  $L2,,/'J

#  C% "A"33  @  # 19   #&    "# A 5"<# #" D###% E  E " %&"#""# 3##  #A%   D"4" #A# #"%&  #8AJ33"#" "#  ##C  "#"% 3" #A   3"K  &   "   #<   "  "  " 3 #J # "#  E    "# @3#  3"#  #8 A% .,,,  .+J    E     #4  "#"  " %#&"C"333"K&%"#& E D"# 75&"#J

"33#C    E  7 !  "# $% &"   "  ## C5 &# "3"8# &#< #" 75"AA#A" 7/

:#< > !3"&K%# %!!/K64% 6#%D</

"3 #83##  #A>

<AA#4'D# >  &#'# >     /#"':#<#  /"&K   

"#"A"3 E  "33#C@ #/

 4&%  <AA#4>           

)+,-)(,,*