Settlement Offer Enforceability After Offeror's Bankruptcy Filing
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertThe court addressed whether a party's post-offer conduct, specifically the filing of a voluntary petition for bankruptcy, extinguished a previously made settlement offer, thereby precluding enforcement of the settlement agreement. The court reasoned that a settlement offer, an invitation to contract, remains open and enforceable until revoked, rejected, or terminated by operation of law, but a voluntary bankruptcy filing by the offeror does not automatically constitute revocation of a prior, unconditional offer, and thus, acceptance of the offer after the bankruptcy filing but before revocation resulted in a binding contract.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generiertArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Settlement Offer Enforceability After Offeror's Bankruptcy Filing: The court reasoned that a settlement offer, an invitation to contract, remains open and enforceable until revoked, rejected, or terminated by operation of law, but a voluntary bankruptcy filing by the offeror does not automatically constitute revocation of a prior, unconditional offer, and thus, acceptance of the offer after the bankruptcy filing but before revocation resulted in a binding contract.
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertCited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of costs.
Volltext
!"!#$" %# !&' ( ! "#$%&
&
) ) )( (( )( *( ( ) ) +% (( ( ) )( ( ( ,))' ( ( - ) ) $" !. ) ( !!&$%&
'()'
(
*/ !0"1" !&""# 02"'34&5 '
06& &&" "7(.882,9+0(6$(.8:2+(0(6 +*8: 29.90(6&00 #;5$<=*9 $%#3/ >"'?& & " 930 @& & "&/ 7 +*8: ?&0"&7(.8+ (.8A/
&)&' 7(.88$ &%7(.8-$&B "?" %" & &" "$ !0 C !&" "D "2"'34&5 "6/
(/ (- 0 (..9$ !/ 0 &"" 3 0 =010 $ =E"0 &10 $ % " & 0 & "& #&&1" ="?&0 "& 2"'34 0 6 = &" "& & " 5 %" & "1F % 11 ""/ #??" >"" &'&" &00 ">"#%"/
-/ :0"(..9$&5 "& ""E 0 E 7(.8* " &" &5 0/G" &)&' 7+*8: <= )' 7(.8-$%" 5 = "" "&&.$-<.$,/H%" " "&0 =0> ?0" 0&&??"" = "" "&& & %& "&E "/" &I " 10 " < &" &"J " &0> &'& = " #>" >$0"%&K 01/&I %&H" & 1 "00>"" "& & " "0 1 "? ="0 "& # "E/ "3 >"" 0&"?" "&$ E"&" %&"""&" &5 "/&I " &0 " # "E$& 00 "&&1>" "< " %" %"& $ 0" " & " " &> & &5 ""% =&"0 %/ <""$ " &"&&/
,/ & =" "& EK $ &00""& =#" &&&<=& &"=&1 "&<= "9:&"&'
"& " "& "% *, %" *:88 2 ' 9 .96 & & ?(9L$0 =&>% "&/ &00 0" %" ?%&>$ & E =& &" = &1 "& 5 & ? " "/ %" & 1&&1" 0" %" ?%&>$ % % & =" "& & 1& #0"E
)+,-)(..+ '-)'
% "/ &" & "& &I $ " =H %" = & "& 1&0">"/
&%""" " ?%&>&I /
9/ 0 0 $ !/ 0 E &" "" 1" ?&"?" E= &" "&& ""%&&" < 5= "" "&&& " " &" "<(9L/
+/ ""&>"C"=%"&??"": 0>(..9$ 0 "%= &" "&&"" /
A/ & &>(..9$&5 "& &3&00""& &&0 "3& "&2"'34&00""&6/='
&" "& "% %"" 5 0"& & "1F$ 0" 0"& &'
" 5 @& =#>" "&$ " "> % "0 $ & 5 = "'
" "&&&%" K "<(.L/"E?&'& ?M "&0 $"%" " "<""0&" #0>/
? 11 %" K " & ?$ " = " 0& " " " >N "0 =#>" "&/ " "& "" O=1 (*P$ ="00>"" "& & "" &I " &1/
= # "E 1>" &I " =#0&"E "/
$ =%" "1 0 " &?"&0 E"?"/
8/ : &%0> (..9$ &5 0 & && &$ & < & I / 0 $ " " & &" "&$ % E'"&" &>30 ""/
:/ &0 "&&(,&%0>(..9$ "& 0&" "&/
*./ *+I%"(..+$&00""&I &/
%" "10 "&?"&0 E"?"/ 1"? "? 3 #" 1>" & "&$ & 0& "%$ " "%>/ & ?"" ? < "&" "&1E"&" " ="00>"" "&&'
&/
)+,-)(..+ ',)'
11 " & "& ="0& %" " & "1FJ = " < I " E 0 %" & &1 "& 0 5=& "&&(9L/
/ (.?%"(..+$&5 "& "" ">0"" "? =??"/
= " < & E&00""&%" "1"?&? 0& "% "&/ &I = " & " 5 0"&$ 0" = / &" "& 0 0 & < &" "&?11= " 0"/$"?"" 8L?7+*8:/
& & 10 "1"? "?<="00>"" "& &'&$ 3#" 1>" &I /
*(/ (.0(..+$&5 0& &&&$& E&I " " 0 &?&05"&" "&1">/ 0 ?" 0K0$(-0(..+/
*-/ (,%"(..+$I11<=" "&&"&< & /
/ !/ " &"1 E 0I&" %" E " " %$%=5" =# "E/& "&&I $ :03 # $=#0&"" %>N "0 5" /"1" 10 E?"?&0 %"& %5$< # "E/
!/ 0" E&I %" # 8$A903 < >"3/
>/ &01 &3'%> "1$ &5 " & & " E E %" =% #3 &0& " 5 1 @''#/ > %" > $ >" E = &" "&=> 1?M ?&/
/ ((0"(..+$&5 0& &I& E%"5" &I %" # <>"3:$(903 / &0& " @''#%$ 1 &0>%>& /
( )
*/ I 0 " % I"" "& &0 $ & %>2 /9+ &"Q&1" "&I"""((&%0>*:,*'
)+,-)(..+ '9)'
' ( .9J / +- / * " / &" & 0"" "% *( 0>*:89' ' 9*.6/
(/ Q " (( " * &" ? Q010 " &" ((I" :A: 2 ' G A..6 %&" EQ & "& & " "& K & ?&0 Q &" "& &1 &0 / &" "& "% " & "& & Q" "& &?&0 < Q?? "&@& " " E"2 /((/( / > 6/ &" ? &" & % & &" "& 0 " < % 5 " * ( "&" "& " / Q EQ ?" 1" 1%&"" /
-/ #" + 2 /98<A:6?"5&0"?"E< &&%&""?">N "0 $&00Q Q3$930@& 2 / *: / - &" Q" "& &" ? Q010 " &",I"*:8A2 '*-.6/
/ 930 @&$ #E & "& &0& $ ""$ E &10 2 /A9/* 6/
"&" "&$%"1"*,I%"*::,$ " &" & 0 0&" "EQ "" "&I""& & "?" "&@&& ">2!0&" &"$ *::-$/,*(:6/
>/ G& Q " 9: " * $ ? & "& 930 @&$ 5"00(#$&" 5(.L?/ & ?&"$3& "&&00 &00""&Q#" $ 0 &"$&&I & "&&& "1$ ?#(9L$""& I "?" " 0 &0 ">% 3$Q#0&" Q010 E "2 /9:/, / 6/
/ & %5 &"Q "*(:&"& "& " "& "% (9 0 *:+* 2"'3 4 6$ & &&E=" 10 <Q "9: $" %E$&%" ""& & "& 1"1 " & < >N " @&%"$" " &#" >E &" $ ">"?"" 0&H " "&$ " &" & "& %" & & "1 % "" Q "" "& & % E Q " Q" &"/ & %" >" "& 5"% @& %"$ E&"" <" "&H 0 "E& "&&& "1$ ""0& " E " "&&" &0"<" 3>""0" / @&%"%" &?&%,30@&$E" " %< " "00>Q#>" "&2!0&"$*:8-$/,(86/
)+,-)(..+ '+)'
""$ "> &" E %5 &"$ E Q& &" Q &1 "& ?% Q "" Q "" "& (9L &0" < "&" "&/
&0> '" ?"1 Q5"1 E &I & "& &" "?"&& "1/
,/ && "1Q"?" "&50"&0&"$" 0 0" &H & & "& Q"0& "& #&&3"'"2 /98/( 6$<%&"= " 0K0"%2 " &> $" "&"#> "E &1"E 1?R"$*:+A$/*-*96/
/ G& I" & "> ?$ &" Q" 3 0" " & / & ?&"$ " 5 Q >&0 "$ " "" "&"'"& &">$"? &##E %" > & &0$ 11 & 0 < &"$&" & 00 > 31$&" $""E% E&/EQ&& 5 10 "0& 2 C:(,8$A--* K " 6/
>/ %51" "?<Q&"1"Q "*(8"( $& 5 "<Q "98"( &?"0 Q" "&" / ?? $ " & &"1 E Q" Q3 "'" &%" I "?" "& ?"" "&0K00"&""%"$E""0"E" Q5" Q & Q / & "&$ @& %"$ Q >N "0 & "&10 0" &">$<&" "&EQ""&Q3&0'
0 5 &10 / & " 0" " Q0 Q3 "'"$ & %" E$ 0"& ""%"$ & < ?&0 #" && % 15 " >N "0 @&, , 2!0&"$*:8+$/,,((6/
/ =3$ &I & 5 5"1 "'/ & " 5 %"$ 0 & "1S / ?" E " &5 #"E$ E #??"$ >" =>"$ & ">"#%"0&"?""/ & "0 < E & " & $ &">"" = %" < = %0 "E="=1" =&10 / 1"?3 & /
9/ / ?#"&" "&& ?$ " ? ? > # & " & "&#&'&2 /9:/* ( 6/
)+,-)(..+ 'A)'
>/ &E "& I "?" E 0 &0 "> % 3$ =#0&" =010 E "$ 0 & < &" "&$ & ?$ ? # &0>$ &E %" = 1 "?" < ($,.
03 & "%" ?T "3 2 /9:/- / 6& &E&0>& ="0& $"00 %"= 1 2 /9:/- /> 6&?11"0"&0& 2 /9: /- / 6/
&5& # &%&"%1& I % %"<=#>" "&2 /A+/* 6/
/ "> 0"" "? &T &%&" =" "& 0 $E" && " = "9:"*$ - , &15""15&BO"& I "?" P &B &0 ">% 3$=#0&" =01'
0 E " 2 )A88)*::A (- 0> *::A ? " 6/ "&0> & ?&" < =0"" "&$ &0 &%&"$ & #E<&"1" K /"& ?%&> < &1 "& & "0& $ 0 &" ?" % /&%" & 00 ?"" "&&%&" "% % "" =1" " 0 2/ U $ " &" 0""'
"?$N*::*$/-97*+96/
/ =3$ 0 Q& ?(9L/& " " &1 "&=?? "&= &">/ 1 $& "0 <E& " & $& " " ? &'&$ "#>" > &"$ &00 "'/ = $ & =& "$ & "> 0"" "?$ 1"? & ? &0>/
+/ &%" " 0""11&I & "& Q"0& /
/ Q "-"-310 Q" "&&"& "& " "& "% (A ?%" *:A8 2 ' 9 .9 .*6 "% 4
VG& & "&="0& $<&" "&E= % "<=#>" "&$"<=5"= "%" &00"$"'
" & "$ & ? =53 9. 0( E" =""% 1>" "0" 4
/ "1% "& # =53($9.03 J
)+,-)(..+ '8)'
>/ "1&>"E?" %=#&"@& &00 "1 % "1-.J
/ "1#&"@& ?T 1" <,$9.03 &05"00/
&$? & & "&="0& &" 58L? 05"00*..0(V/
>/ "> 0" E " Q0K#" &" " Q E&E$ " & 0&H$ QE" & "1F & &%&"10 ?& ">&" J Q"&%" E" &%> $"&%" "$0K0> $& & "&E"&" " <&%"%&" "%&""E" 0 < "&" "&$ & ? & ">$ ? " E" Q%" I< %" < & >N "0 5" / 0"3?" " 0"&" "$0K0"&" "&5$ Q " E ? %&"" 0" < & "> "& & ? & "> " %" "0 < $ E" "0"E" "E0 EQ&" 1%Q%" &>N "&?" & "%" 2 )+9-)(..," ?" 6/
0 & ""> &E=" =1" 0" *..L ?<&0 &%&"">N "0 ="0& /
/ =&$ 11 %$ = ? ,: 0($ K &"&00 ="0& E"? "< &0 1 & " < +*($9 0( 2,:)85*..6/ =3$? & %"&I *=.(-0(/
% E" 3$ &I "&" "& 1 & & ?/
A/ / <50"E "&&0 ">"" &I &"% 3$ =#0&" =010 E " E" & " = # "E$ &1 < & < = " *9 ?" < & "&I""E"0"&" 0"/& & "&%" & & "& >I "% " E" " 3 & "& #EQ3J& "&" <Q &" " " I10 / &EQ # "E 0 E 0 &" &" "&& && " Q& &" Q &" "&& "E& ?Q53(.L2 / *9/* 9:/* 6$1" ?" Q # "E&" "& ""> & &" &1 "& & ? (.L
2 )+A.)(..9& &>(..9J )+,)(..*-.I%"(..*6/
)+,-)(..+ ':)'
"&" "&1 ?0 = # "E$& I"'
"> " E= & " & "& I""E " 0"$" "&%&"=" "&<=0"" "&$'
" = "0" E =53 & => &%&" =" "&
2 )+.:)(..,9&M (..,J )9:)(..,(.I%"(..,J /G $ " &" 0"" "?$ #N $ *:8,$ / --('---J / U $ &/ " /$ /-,'-+$ 7 *+.'*+:6/ H 30 $ %" & %" &00$ 0 &1"0 " =& E= 3 & "?$ ? "&" "& & " 5 &"/ &E= %" &>"1 &"$"&%" 0""0"2 )+.:)(..," 6/
>/ #E ?&" E = &" 0"" "% " %" &00""& & "%$ = &" & &" ="0& " $ ?& "& & " < # " "1 2 )*(:)(..- 0 (..-J / '
$" K %I10"" "?" /'/ /! $ 1&> " K $ &" =%"&0 010 " &"$N C?& '''!"$*::+$/(.*6/ &" & "0" <50"" 0 = 0& "?& M0 >" %" = &" #"E & "%$ &0& "" /
/ =3$ =0> %" "" ?%&> &I / 3 &$ "> 0"" "?$ ="0& % E" " "&0> 0 "3 = # "E & "&$ E & E= & = &"'
"& & "$ 0 = " > & &%&" =" "& " 5"'"/ = ""<I " E&00""&&?"0= &"'
"& &$ & E 1"? & < 1 %" " K /
8/ " "$ & &# &I = T & 1 "00>"" "& & "E & & >N "'
0 /
/ >1=" " 31& ="00>"" "& &/
>/ G& "" 15 &" $ " Q " < Q0"" "& Q"00"&?" &" "%&% Q% E && / 1" "& 1%&" 0 "3 &" & "& &> Q&?&0" &I %" "& 0 "3& "& Q010 " " 5 ">N "0 " "&/ %#$ Q & &>I %" &" 2 /-/+ J )+9-)(..,(,&M (..,6/
/ 1"?&"% "K /
)+,-)(..+ '*.)'
:/ &&" 0?&$&I /
0&0 WC -=.../' 0" < #1 & $ " &I&" 0 &""0 / 5'" & &0$ &I&" 0 &""0 $<%<Q" "0"0" & WC(Q9../'/2 / 8A 6/
% () (
/01$ 2
%> & " I (. ?%" (..+ !0 C !&" "D "& ""&&00""& && 0 "3& "&*+I%"(..+J
1$2
I J
0 < #1 & $ " &I&" 0 &""0 $ 0&0 WC-Q.../'J
&<!&""# 0"0" & WC(Q9../'$< #1& $"&I&" 0 &""0 J
&00"E K < ! "#$ %& & $ < &00""& &&0 "3& "&$""E= 0 & "& #&&1"="?&0 "& <!!&$%& !&""# 0/
G"1 4 !/H#3$" $!0&%H W"$!/ #"$!0&$ I1/
&0 ">0"" "?4
1??"3'I" 4 " 4 /"&'G"1" C/H#3
)+,-)(..+ ')'
&"&?&0 K &00"E5 "/
3%$ 1??"34
)+,-)(..+