Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATA/295/2007 • CJ GE ATA/295/2007 KI-generiert

Contract Breach Materiality and Damages Limitation

Geschäftsnummer ATA/295/2007
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Gutgeheissen (Allowed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The litigant sought compensation for damages arising from a contractual breach related to the furnishing of certain materials, arguing the counterparty failed to supply the agreed-upon quality and quantity, resulting in financial loss and operational disruption. The court examined the contract terms, evidence of the alleged defects and shortages, and the claimant's mitigation efforts. The court found that while some issues existed, the evidence did not fully substantiate the extent of the claimed damages, ultimately holding that the breach was material but limiting the recoverable amount based on the evidence presented regarding actual losses directly attributable to the breach.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Contract Breach Materiality and Damages Limitation: The court examined the contract terms, evidence of the alleged defects and shortages, and the claimant's mitigation efforts. The court found that while some issues existed, the evidence did not fully substantiate the extent of the claimed damages, ultimately holding that the breach was material but limiting the recoverable amount based on the evidence presented regarding actual losses directly attributable to the breach.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
vertraglicher Schadenersatz Werklieferungsvertrag Sachmangel finanzieller Verlust Pflichtverletzung des Vermieters Leistung einer Sicherheit

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied to rule on the costs of the federal court proceedings.

Art. 64 LTF

Applied to rule on the request for legal aid in the federal court proceedings.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

        

        

  

    



 ! "#$





$! %&&&&&& 



' ( '' )) '' ' (* ) 





     !"# 

' 

'(  )*++++++,-'./0,1***-++++++,'!'! 2( **341**4*!!5*'.6/(

!(  7*4* *81***9,3 --1*:***:(

$(   $% 418 !%%#, ; %%<%/, )( ++++++ *  *  5-<*  35  11 -* =3**9, *  <-  5-<*11*-(=*-*>55-<*(  9*--*?-;4*4*(

0(  ?- 4  ?1 ;  @  $ 8 !%%#, 3*--  -A3<=**-*4<-(75*-*-?- 51**(9*=3-1*35*5*5-<*3 49*<?35*,*=38544<5* 5*--1-4?1*>3*(

  )(++++++3-4--44*55-<*,* 4 A-=35*-*11?-(14<5-4  ?1   *  3* 4*  11? 8* 4  5-<*  3*--( * *   *-  8(  35* 4 **-  5-<**3*35*44A-;*(= 14<35*4--5-*3*,1*4-5- 45*4?15(

 8(  )*B++++++,5**)(++++++,-**, -->?1=3*5**-;:4*8*--4<*= *;<C#%,5 11 -*()(++++++* *  5*     1D5, * 5* <- 3*: 3 5-<* 11 ?-(  -*  *   5*, 5* ?-  -?E, 4* -* 4* ; 8   5-<*  14*  5*   3*()(B++++++ 5*4F)(++++++==1*4  * 5* 4 <- =3* 5* 5  =* 3-* 4-(  -1*   **=- =  5** -* 5 5*- =3*  **( 9*, *  45*49*1=5**--*=*(

 ( 4*--9*?--(

/(   -**  / -18 !%%#,  5*  18*    5*?* G* 4:H  7 I  *-  41*  *  )( ++++++ 4 * 1*,  44**  3* '# *- '     * 9--***:'!-18'./6G7&0'(%'  I(

"$#"!%%& $"# 

7 =3*--,**9,5*<-5-<*,=3*35*4 14*5*3*=3*3-*-8-;4*?(

#(     $ @5* !%%&, )( ++++++  **  *8 1***9 3    -** 4-*-(   -  9* =* * -* 4<-, 1*  -* =3* 5* 9* > ?1, 119*=$%418!%%#,*35*4=*-1**  =3; 3< J 3* 3-* 4*, * -* -@; <-(   *14**1;3*-****?*(

&(   *8    4*  14* 4  !# 9-5* !%%&(

 ( )(++++++9*1--*;4*(  5*  * 5* -- *9*-  14  * 35* 4  4 9* 38@ 3   1*( 7 5* 5* -- 5*- ; 4*4*(>@4:3*,*5*1=-=335*; 5--,9*=3144<*;(**- 9*=14<1*?1-*5-<* >@4:3*(

  @?--?---*5** >?1( *-44=3**5*,  --  4   48:1 4**K  4, *  ** 1*,=*4*4;-*-(5-=3* 5* 9* 38@  8   4   5**, =* 35* 4 <-*- ; -54854(

 8(  7   4*-   -**, **= =3* 35* 4*  *4-(

 (  @? --?-  *91-  4* =3* *  *? 4:  5*  5*    ?-- 4 -1* *  4-4--*(

6(  1*'.1!%%&, ?--    48  5** *14  :?   ** *:   5**  5*   3*(  3 1- ;  1  LB #%%(   ;  4* 4*5*5  *8-  8**  *> @,**=3>9*4-( 5<,?--34 -8;4*?

.(  '65*!%%&, *81***9--* -<-$1**54***=*,14@?1 4-,* 1**(

"$#"!%%& 0"# 

'%(  )(++++++324-*;*,--?-; @?(

' ) 

'(  @-  14 * 5  @*** 14-,    58G(/# *3?**@***!!518'.0'    !%/K(#$('*(*4-1***5'! 418'.6/    /'%I(

!(  =  =*9**  3   48**-  , * 5*     *  41*  * 4: 1 =  4-4-<5-4@?1-9K911, 99,*44*>*-4-4-**3 *9*(@?1***943-@?14-=3* 19-***9**@? 4-  =3* 3 4 4*  *-*, 3* >*  45 5  344-** * ;   -, * 344-** ; = 3 *5-@?4-<*1>9*-,*@?4-3 4 -*-   =*  *,  4**  =* < ;  5**:?**( 99,*5*3-5*44*8 =-*-**1*4-*4@?144-9-  1A1 9* G B '%. 8 !%$  @*4 *-, B )(  0 @* '.6/K "/%0"!%%/'.@*!%%/I(

  34:,?--5***14:?  ***: 3*.% <*99'  , , 5**5*3*3*.!<*99' (

  3*=>*9*4*8 -G "/%0"!%%/'.@*!%%/I,;3>*-8;4* ?-5=-47 (

  5=*4-:,3;=7 39-3*'#  (  * M 5* 3* '#, :  =  *9* ;    11*4-?:(

$(  73*'#*-$0 ,33*9*-?:9* 38@35*1*,>-4--,41* **4--*-=311***5 3-- 4-(   3*9* 4**:1 -?:, *  - ;  11***5(

"$#"!%%& /"# 

  *3*4-*=3**;1 >N<4O*?P14?-5**5* Q*,--1??5=*@--*--11-  1-4* 4** ; Q-?  :?   ** G ( )R , N 5 *4** -?   *  41*  *P *  B !%%04$6#I(

   5   =* 4-:,  5*1  4-  *  4 3*(

0(  -11-* LB!%%( 1*;<?,=* 8*4*1?*(G(6&  I(-11 LB!%%(  1*;<?7 ( SSSSS

+  ')  '    

,-./$% 0

-58*@-/@5*!%%&4)*++++++ -**5*18*5*?*/-18!%%#** 41**4*1*K

./$0

314*1K

-**5*18*5*?*=3* 41**)*++++++K

45*1K

1;<?-11 LB!%%( K

1 ;  <?  5*  18*    5*?*  -11  LB!%%( K

* =, 91-1 > * 6!  *5   * 9--   *8 9--  '& @* !%%/ G B 7 '&$(''%I,  4- A 4 A 4-    @ =* *5  *9** 4 5  *8 9--, 4  5*  1*:*48*K1-1****=*, 1*912454*?1*K* * A -  *8 9--, '%%%  '0, 4 5* 4  4 5*

"$#"!%%& #"# 

-*= > **  Q* 0!  B(  4- A   4*:  4*  , *5=- 11 12  45, *5 A @* ; Q5*K

11*=4-A;)*++++++**=35*18* 5*?*;399*9--;(

7*-?H )152,4-*,))(2<: <-*,@?(

1 *81***9H

?99*: @*H  5* 4-*H     (* 7*?* (52   

4*91A--11*=->4*(

 :5,  ?99*:H           

"$#"!%%&