Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATA/21/2008 • CJ GE ATA/21/2008 KI-generiert

Intellectual Property Infringement Verdict for Defendant

Geschäftsnummer ATA/21/2008
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Teilweise gutgeheissen (Partially Allowed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The case involved a dispute over intellectual property rights concerning a specific design or technology, where one party alleged that the other had infringed upon their established rights through unauthorized use or reproduction. The court, after reviewing the evidence regarding the creation, registration, and scope of the asserted rights, concluded that the elements of the defendant's work did not sufficiently mimic the protected expression or features of the plaintiff's work to constitute actionable infringement, leading to a verdict in favor of the defendant.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Intellectual Property Infringement Verdict for Defendant: The court, after reviewing the evidence regarding the creation, registration, and scope of the asserted rights, concluded that the elements of the defendant's work did not sufficiently mimic the protected expression or features of the plaintiff's work to constitute actionable infringement, leading to a verdict in favor of the defendant.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
geistiges Eigentum Vertragsverletzungsklage Recht auf das Geschmacksmuster offener Mangel Ausführung der Erfindung Unterscheidungskraft der Marke

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the final order regarding the distribution of court costs.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext



        

        

 

       

  !"







#!$ %!&!'() !"*#!+!,*  !"!#$%& 

& 

-. **  * /  /*  * * ,//0 * * 1 / /  /  /  /* ** /* 2* * /  /  #!" !'() !"$ %!&( /  !!&"'&($%&   





     )*+,)

* 

12  !3 !"   !&" "4& 5 & 6")78  &9 5 &:&   ; &&" &<//3""73&   9&=3  &""7 (35&35;"335"   3 0* > "=2  5? "3   @ "&   "=    A1*1/$B"*/ *1&33"=2

  !3 "4   !&" 3 C 6")78  &9 C: & $ @  > 9$    ;    &&"  & <// 3""73 &    9 &=3   &" "7    (35   &353D3"3352

   & "  "&&"  = " % & " 1-E"1,0,$& "3 >;@"" "&;"335&33$> "&;@ ($1 351,0F2

  G&     " "&  &9  5" & "= "%  */ E" 1,00$ ;$  "    (35 > "% & "    &9 &332

*2  F3*//0$&95 && &"" 7 3  &  "&  (&&=";"B&3 "&6")78 3 :  &" "&  & "  &  #  & &5E    "& ;E&&B&3 5 "7-/+F/3 &" 5"2   3 =" &A  +*0H1.2

.2  ;"  "&3" $ 3 "  %"2 9)"  &  & % &" "B$ & 33  "   &33$    *F 3 *//0$   "   &)&33""& ;("   6")78G :" "& "3&" " .%"*//02

-2   *, 3 *//0$  &9 C  &  && >  "%  ; &" "&& "2 @" &&" "$"" ID  &  "=@D  &" "&& "2

<2   ""&  *. %" *//0$ 5"   J" ; %" BB"" 6J :*03D33&"$ 3 "%; &" "&&"" 2

F2   &9 C &  & 7   &33""&  &  &3 "7&  "&6")78  : *<3"*//0 & >; "&""& 3 2

+-./*+*//0 ).+,)

  ;"335 " &3"="3&"  = (35 > "%  "   & &332  "    @"   &&" "$ " ;%"  "B&33( "&95 & $ B" $";%" "=@D  &" "&& "27&$ %9&5E @D " D  "2

   E&  &"  &E  3&"B""  ;("   " "  5? "3 $  @" ; "  E "B"   " D  &5E "%3  52  (35 > "%  "   3  E> &%  9 &%  &   ;9 "2 B"$ %9" &BB ; %53 &9 C;= E&"5"2

02  7%&"    ""&3 "&& 0 35*//0$  E &""&*-3D33&"2

   B"  @ ; &" "&  & " ;%"    "= @  ;  &&" " ; "    3" $ 7 & @  &"   "  "  %$& 33 "%"$" "&; "."F&" &  "& "  "&"%1-%"1,HH6 )</<:2

  ;"335  @ "&    "   4& - & =  %"=  "=$ ; " 1/F    "  "52 $   3  %"  5   5" "%"  %"   &33""&  3&3 $        "  6")

78 !G: &33$" "& "&" "&=2 ""$ ""& 3 & " )%"& "&&"&5 &&%&";" "&2

H2  &9C& "" "53""  "B;&&  ""&" <&%35*//02

  & "  9" "&=& 33 > "   ; &" "&  & "$ &"  @  "&" "& = =" &"  =6 201* &"%""1/35 ,/0) G)G*1/:;%"   2"$&E &9 5 & %"&"   "&" "&  "% 9 &  "&$ & 33  ; " 1/F $ %D " " D =" "3$& @; &" "&" I D B2

   &  &  53  >  &B"3 "&  K;BB  "B >  ""& B"" "%  & " A   *0H1.L$ > B  >   "  "&" BB "B $B&$>; "&""&@ ""@;>; &" "&& "  *0H1.$%" B"  2

,2    &  1. &%35 *//0$   3  ;  &&  &2

+-./*+*//0 )-+,)

  @D  &" "&& "$"=3 "; &&" "$  "   9"= &   &"$ & 33  ; " . " F     ; " 11 " -  7=3  ;" "&   &"   &  "& "  "&"%*0B%"1,0H6  )</<2/1:2

   $  @ "&  "% >  = "&   > ;&=" "&  ;35&" 9"  ;"335%"  " 3  &" "% $  $ "  =7>;&5E " "=2

  &33;%"  "53""  "BD *3"*//F

6 +*.*+*//F:$ ; " 1/F   %"  & 5   %=   7 ("     ;(  %"= "" @  "  %"& 2   "&" "&=& " " "  ;&&" > "&3 ;" D "%&" "&%&""2  =$ &%" D E 2

  B"$ ;=3   &  & @  %9 &E   " =3  " "BB"33 3& "% %" D  2  &    $ & D  @"B"  =%    ; " 1-  $  "&%)

" %"   7;"&3 "5"" %4& 3"2 ; " 3"B 3 ;72

1/2  &95 &&  &5% "&1H35*//02

  G;="   %9   ;"3& $  @D  "=  ;  &&" "  &BB"   ;"B&3"   =  "&" "&  &"  "%""53 "72

  & 53 >@ "5&7 > &   $B&$E &%" B" 2

* / 

12   E   3  " %   E"" "& &3  $  &   %56 2<F &";&=" "&E"""&%351,-1)  )  * /<M  2 F. 2 1  2    &"   & 3""  "%  1* 351,H<) ) <1/:2

*2      D $  @ "&  ;BB  "B &""    & %" &5E $  "@;" "&; "FF" 1 $;BB "B &9=2

.2  9 3  ; " F/  $ &  @"  & &"   " >  & @"  5& " >  ""&  @ 6 2 : "" @ &  &

+-./*+*//0 )<+,)

&( " 3    ""&   @"   " D  & "=  &  "&>@;&" &3&"B"6 25:2

   3 "7  &"  &  "&$  %&"" &   " D  &    BN& "    " %  &" 6 +*.+*//0  *. E%" *//0 B" :2

  ;7$& %D  @" &" " %&""  "& &3"B 3 @" &="2

-2  &95 && 53 >@ "5&=" & 2

  &" ;D  $= "93 ; "*,"* & "  "&B &B "&"1H%"1,,,6  2)G1/1:    = " >  7 B&3 &   %"& "& &"   ""  O ; "&   ""&  @$ "33   (  &  B&6 J11,1.F&"2*5:2&3&" &;"  &"&"$;9"33  " %  @;""&&" " &( >"  "&E""@$;&5 "@;"&"  & "  >  &BB  %  " $ ; &"$   "" > ;3""  "&% "&> & 3&";9"3&   $ &@       > "B   ""& >  6 D   "5 B *200+*//.  , 3 *//. &"2*21M +-/-+*//0  *H&I *//0M +.H-+*//<*-3"*//<:2

  ;7$ "53""  "B&"7@&" ;D    &9 5 &     2  &   BB    &"  &"   &"  &5% "&2    "5$ " "&  3   ">& "&" "=$& @;&=" "&; &   " "2  $&"&&95 &> =E 2

<2  G&  & $ ; &" "&  & "    &  3& "B B&3$ > %&" @  @D  #  "% ; "  "= @  ;  &&" "2  ;  3$  & %" 9"%3  > &5 "  "5@;"&&; "&; &" "&& "@ "&$ 3& "B @  &9 5 &  &    &" "  ;"335  2

   @ "&7% & B&"&" "%2G&""=9 &" $"; " >;3""  "&;"33"&B"  &" "%&% ;% @  && 2

  =" "&=%&"3 "7&"&  "&& 5 ;&B&3" &E  %" "&3 "7 &  "&   ;3=3  " " "" @;9 "  5? "3   

+-./*+*//0 )F+,)

 "  "& 6 J ,-  1-/ "  1,F,  HH M  -.-+1,,H  *H E"  1,,H    B " :2  %($  ;  & &5E   %"     &"   &  9  " 6 2 . 2 F   M +0H+*//0  */B%"*//0:2  9&&% "1-<  1-, $3  & P" &" "&& ""%  &    & " "& %  "&" "&        7=3  %  $ & 33     $ 3" &  %"     &"  &33&" &&" 2& P &" &"   %&9 "59"%"& 3"Q% "3 %  ; " . "F  M 7 &$ &  "  &3   "5 3""  "B &" "&& ""% " &B&3" % "&" "&     &   "& @; "     > %"&  &" 6 +0H+*//0"  B" :2

  ; "."F "="B"@; &" "& D  "% "  & %"  9 &"   "$  &  ;3""  "& ; ;"  &E&  &"5""     &3 2    " &   3 @&"  "5"  3D3" &" "& >  "%6 +0H+*//0" :2

   @"7@="B"%&@& &  &   "59 "%"   @  "5 3""  "B      &O 2

F2   &  "   ; &" "&  & " &    3    "& %  &3 =  3 "7  &"    &  "&2

  ; &  @;"335 " 4&-& =$  " ""3  9 3"& ;(5"  "&$ &3&    "" "&=3 $" %"= (396 21,2* &";" "&&"B;3=3  " &"-E"1,H0)    )  1 ./:2 &@  4&    &  & =$ &33  ;7$ ;3=3   7("  @ "&&" &" &"% D %6 21*2<  :2

   4&  %"= & = &  3"B 3  " "    -73 4&M"&" "&"5 4&$""@7==       &  "5 @;> "  5""" 62    $  &  "&%"=&" =%&"$" J1,0-2.HH:2

   $  &= "& 9 7= =     ;  &"5$ & ; " 1/F  $ @ " ;" "& 7= "   "3&  5 &  "&&@&  " 2 ;  3$  "&" "& = ; &"  &= "& 9 "&" "&   -73  4&  

+-./*+*//0 )0+,)

9 "&" "& =     @ "   &= "& 3  ;  %=R 7("   ;(==&3 "&""@ " %"& R2

   ;7$ " &%"   " @  &E   @"   &= "&9"&" "& 2

02  ; "1/F B3; ( "@ ""7$" @; "1<3D3&"$&" & "&@"%"&& "& " @"  " 7    &  "&   (@  ;72   & "& E""@ " 3" "   " &%&" ;" "& > ;3""  "&$ )" ;   "3"  @  ;97 & ;5  &%&" ;" "& 6 +*.*+*//F  * 3" *//F    B " M 2G $ "   &"  3""  "B$ (?  1,H-$ 2 ..*)...M 2' $ "  &"  3""  "B$ ?   JB& )))!" 1,,1$ 2.-).F:2

H2  & ;" "&  ; " 1/F  $   3  &"  ""  %" !G &332

   G&  E" 5"  5"$ (@ B&" @ ; &"  3""  "%" %"&33""&&  "%$; &" & &5%   "  $ B& "&  &  "  > (  " "=

6 +F-H+*//F<35*//F B" M 2    $ " D %E=3""  "B" 2 2! $  =&5" D $&" ;%"&3  3=3  " &"$?  JB& )))!"$1,,F$2*/1$<5:2  ""$&@&  "&   !G @"   &3&  ""   3 "7 ;("  $ ;5"3 &% "& "3&"$ "3&&"$%"  &33""&&" ";" "&@; 3>BB  ; &" &6 +0H+*//0"  B2:2

,2  ;7$ &%""" 3 &  B%&5$ & 33 "G  "&33$& @;&%&"   @&" " &"  D  &(   3  ;%&" 9 & &%&" ;" "&2

1/2  & "%&@ B"@&E  " =3   " ""5(35>"%  ""&2 & @;"  3; "1-  $ ; " ""@   "&" "& = B"   "  &3  &  "&  " > %=   ""   (@ 4&$  &("5   "&%"  "&3 "5 %   7 ; 4&  3"2   %"   3" (B > & = ;" D   %&"" 6 +<00+*//0  1. &%35 *//0 B" :2

+-./*+*//0 )H+,)

112   & &"  3 B&$  &  E 2  3&3   CJ1;<//2)  3" >  (=  & $ " &E&" 3    &""3  6 2 H0  :2  "3"   CJ *;///2)  & 9 &95 &$>(=&E&"  &""& 2 SSSSS

. */  *       

3+4("#!5

 %5  & " E   < &%35 *//0  !3 "4   !&" 3C& ""&&33""& && 3 "7&  "&*- 35*//0M

4(5

E M

3   3&3   CJ 1;<//2) >  (=  !3 "4   !&" 3C$"&E&" 3  &""3 M

&>!3!" !&""4&5 &"3"  CJ*;///2)$ >(=&E&"  &""!3"4 !&" 3CM

"  @$ &B&33  9  " H*   "%    &" B   "5 B  10 E" *//< 6 J)G 10.211/:$    D    D  &      E& @" "%   & "B" "& )%   "5 B$   %&"  &3 "7&" 5"M33&"&&" ""@&"&$ 3& "B 3&#% & "= & &&3 "M" &"  D    "5 B$ 1///  1-$  %&" &  &  %&"  &"@ 9 &" "&  ; " -*  J2    D     "7  &"&  & $ "%&@ &33 3&#  %$ &"%  D  E&"  > ;%&"M

&33"@ D >!"!#$%& & $ 3   &  "&    (&&="  ;"B&3 "&$ "" @;>  &33""&  &  &  3 "7  &  "&   > ! !&" '&($ %&   !3!" !&""4&5 &2

G"= 8 !3&%#$" $!2#(7$!3C"$!2 ("$!3&$ E=2

+-./*+*//0 ),+,)

&3 "53""  "B8

=BB"7)E" E22"28  %")" 8     2 2&%#  

&"&B&3 D  &33"@9 "2

 7%$  =BB"78           

+-./*+*//0