Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATA/150/2005 • CJ GE ATA/150/2005 KI-generiert

Contractor Payments Deemed Wages Based on Employer Control

Geschäftsnummer ATA/150/2005
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Abgewiesen (Dismissed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The dispute concerned the proper classification of payments made by a contracting entity to subcontractors, specifically whether these payments constituted wages subject to withholding and related payroll taxes, or rather payments for services that should be reported on informational returns. The court reasoned that the determinative factor was the degree of control retained by the contracting entity over the manner in which the work was performed, finding that because the entity controlled the means, methods, and sequence of the work, the relationship was one of employer-employee, thus classifying the payments as wages subject to statutory withholding obligations.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractor Payments Deemed Wages Based on Employer Control: The court reasoned that the determinative factor was the degree of control retained by the contracting entity over the manner in which the work was performed, finding that because the entity controlled the means, methods, and sequence of the work, the relationship was one of employer-employee, thus classifying the payments as wages subject to statutory withholding obligations.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Subunternehmervergütung Werkvertrag Zahlungsmittel Lohnabtretung Werkvertragshaftung Arbeitsentgelt

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the imposition of costs in the final order.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

        

        

  

    

 

  !"#$





%%%%%%%%%% 



& ' && (( && & ') ( 





     !"# 

& 

'(  )* )++++++++++, -  '%'., *///- 0 12,  // 34*//-5/-/2-012!%6'%78(

!(   !# 2*6 !&&$, 0 &.9##,  //  2/     )9/://32/  9*(

  419*/;,-4-2-9/034493 //*42///-2-<2-9/2 /2( /2-09)//,=3>4 -2/  // 2  5 ?/ -69/     //  32@//* A2?/-/6/( /*4-     3    2/  //  59 4/   6/?- 0 /  //   4  < /2  -4  2-9/   3/-;/4;/34-/-/-45(

   *4*  /- 3/ 3 4/  5*/(  5-,03/B,?)*)++++++++++2/ -4-2-9/3-/-4-32/03-5< 5   (  4,  3-/ 4 4    ?  4*//*4////;/6/5/* (

7(   -//  !' C2/ !&&#,  2/  *6/    2/5/ D/ 41E  F G  4-  2/* 0 3  3/--/-?32//;-51<15 // /1    3/ 'H /- !   / ;--   ///1'%-*6'%#.D IF8$'(&'G(

  -/* < ;/,  F  2/ ?/  )* )++++++++++  4/ 3 /;/ *-/( / /, -6/  '8 C2/ !&&# 4  *-/ /F ,-/40/4?34 (

$(  /4-!.C2/!&&#,)*)++++++++++41  /6*///;2/*(

#(    /  *4/ 4  $ * !&&#,   <4-?C?/,2/*/2/(   2/ 4 2-   */ -/ 4//1* 6*<( F , /-, 3*4>9/ 32/  6 2//6//-(  5 2/ 4?32/4-/150B-3(

"!$%"!&&# 7"# 

   32/ C*/ ;/ 36C 3 ?? * *///2  /-/?32/*-/*/;**/// *   J  2// 0   2 /;/(   *///3/2/*(

H(   4-  F   4/-   -// ?/  4/2/ 4  4/6//-/(

8(  F?/,--5-0C5(

& ( 

'(  C-  *4 / 2  C/// *4-,    26D(#H /K5//C///!!2*6'%$'    !&#L(H7('/(/4-*///2'! 4*6'%.#    #'&G(

!(   ' C2/ !&&#,  2 /4//      -  2/5D!&&!4(!8H8G( ;/,/4//// 2,/1344/??3</;////1 /41-2/5,*-23/ / * -5/ 4  /, ; <4/  -/-  341( 3         7' -*6 !&&$ ?/ 344/? 0  D "'8"!&&#''C2/!&&#G(

7(  ?/2*/;///*9,4<*44 6/?,-4,*4--/4K2/0 ,K2/-5<5?/2//2 //?K<2-9/?//2D(7$(7 G(

  ///-// ?/--- 45,344-3/7$/-7 4-/-(

$(  4,//2-9/*6/4>*/0 //44/412/;;-B 23/%3-53*//4 2-9/0///1!86'%8HD IF8$'(#'G(

   341,   6/5/ ;/5/  !&&$ -C0   4*/  /-/---;/*-4*-/ / '8C2/!&&#(

   4, )* )++++++++++   4 ?  C  ;/   4/40** 0(-?;/ 2--(

"!$%"!&&# $"# 

#(  /-?3/35// 03/;/-513/ 'H/-! ,F ;//44-/// 341?4-32/*,?/4/24 4*//,4?3>;/*-(

H(   ?3  // 3 4*/  / 4/ '%78, )*)++++++++++ 3 C*/ ;/ 36C 3 ?? *    3<--(/44/;/-6/ 24/-;/?34/44/(

8(  C-(3///5,-** MA7&&(  */095D(.8 G( NNNNN

*  &( + &    

,-.#/

- 26   /C-  !. C2/ !&&# 4 )* )++++++++++ -//2/*6/2/5/!'C2/!&&#L

.#$/

CL

*095-** MA7&&( L

/ ?, ;*-* < / %8  /2   / ;-- K5// C///,4->4>4-,42//*///;,   C 1  /;//, 4 2  /6 ;-- L  *-*/  ///?/,*/;*:424/5 */L//>-/<*4/*/ /6 ;--, '&&&  '$ L  4- >   4/1  4/  ,/2?-*:42,/2>C/0K2/L

/?4->0)*)++++++++++,//2/*6/ 2/5///?30K;;/;--0(

F/-5E )(:91,4-/,)*M/,,C5(



"!$%"!&&# #"# 

* /6*///;E

5;;/1 C/C(E  4-/E     )( / A(:91   4/;*>--/?-<4/(

 12,  5;;/1E           

"!$%"!&&#