Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATA/144/2007 • CJ GE ATA/144/2007 KI-generiert

Defamation Claim Over Financial Practices Publication

Geschäftsnummer ATA/144/2007
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Abgewiesen (Dismissed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The dispute centered on whether certain communications constituted actionable defamation, particularly concerning a publication regarding an entity's financial practices and the subsequent refusal to retract or correct the statements. The court reasoned that the statements, viewed in context, were substantially true and concerned matters of public interest, thus failing to meet the necessary threshold for defamation, especially given the high burden of proof required for demonstrating malice or reckless disregard for the truth concerning a public concern.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Defamation Claim Over Financial Practices Publication: The court reasoned that the statements, viewed in context, were substantially true and concerned matters of public interest, thus failing to meet the necessary threshold for defamation, especially given the high burden of proof required for demonstrating malice or reckless disregard for the truth concerning a public concern.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
üble Nachrede Streitgegenstand Klageschrift Beweislast finanzielle Verfehlungen Verletzung der Offenlegungspflicht

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court orders the appellant to pay the judicial costs.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext



        

        

  

    

 

 !"#$





#$"%%%%%%  !"#$%&' 

' 

& ' && (( && & ') ( 





     "()*"

& 

,/  !'# 000000%   000000,*1(%   '2### 000000% ,(,+ #/  # #32#'##,2,+/

(/  4'  '# 2#  #$ 2##  #5   &#   '2'$# &#6 #'7#"894 :%' 5# 3'$;  22##  #&#& 9

 ,<5&#,+9 # 2#'# 2'#%=# 3 >8&# ?

 @'A ,+9 # 2#'#= # & #5%''$  '% #''& %#% 3B'C $#%' 3#  #''#5#$'6'#=# 3>8&#   32 3&B#'# 3 '' ?

  (< '&2$ ,+ 9 '5#2 #'    2% =  #  3 &# 5&'$  3# #   #&# #  2# 6 7#"89 3!:   $'# #'    #  #'  2# >     '   >    # #  ?

  ,. &# ,-9 &   2 #     #  #'  ' 2#  '#=!/ 000000%D&#  ' 5'#'2 ='&>2 83!#>2'# ?

  (@ ;# ,19 '&  #   2#  '# '   # 2#%''$  '%# ' 5&'$3!,@ ;#,1?

 (.2#(..@9&2# %# &#5&'$3!  * 2#   2E2     #   3#  =  >2  #D  ' F%'2  '6#' D#3&# '# /

@/  ,+;# (..-%=((B,<%3# ## '' 3& 'B %'D3# # '#/' '  $#=  '#'D!/ 000000&# '22###5 #'='#5 # #'' #8,*2$,*<G7 "41+,/.,:/&# '$#D= 6B=B ' !H#'2   8 ##6 &    H'/  8% # &#  55   2#" '  '  '  #  # #'  3& '#" C% 5B#  ##  #6  # /   B   B2# B"'6% # 3&#      #6# #'2#D# # =B'6' B2#/ %#&# # ' '#2B#/ 5#%'' 

)+,-+)(..- "@)*"

I' J (<. '6  3#   #  2#   D  ' F 3 &B#3#  /

  &3 # !/ 000000%623&# '2#   3 BH'28 %D#3 # &6 #5/3# H ##DE  # '>#'2%#3&# '2#=#6 3#=$#6 # ' #8/

    3 BH'28 &#  '5#23> # '>#''6#D #3!/  >>23# 6%#&# 2'  D3 2'2   5# % 3#   #  ' 3#5 3'#    $K'#K##&/

  4'2#'# ##""B2/

+/  (, 2$(..-%'#!/ 000000#5'2'# 

4 D62&# &#'3 #<+ ' =## 2#  '#  ' #       2    = 3 '#  ' D3   ##'  2/ %   > 2'# 8  5# %  4  3 #  ';'   '#'  '2  D#/ 3&'  ' = #  #'#22# 2#'#'# /

</  ##'(1 2$(..-%> '#''$  '% 4  #2#'#!/ 000000= # & #5'  # 2#/ 3!   '&   B6  ' =  >2 '5'#'&3 # ='# 3# /##'5# #  #  &      3> # '   #  #> 2'# # !/ 0000003H'2 # /'3 '# %# # &D!/ 000000 &# #'' 'D3# # '32#$ ### /

  # ##' ' #5#3 =!/ 000000 %3  %=' '#'#2E2;'/

-/   @ ' '$ (..-% !/ 000000% #   $5#  3#  ;##D%## #$2##  #53'7 )@<GG)(..-" : ' #  ; #/  4  3&#   55      8 D  2#  '#'   ##= # '&#'#62#/'  = #  #'#22# '2 /

1/   ##'  2 '&##'  ,( ' '$ (..- 7  <+*)(..-:%#  #$2##  #5; 22 '&##'  2#'  #63E 4 = #'5# ,+;# (..-/

G/      * '&2$ (..-% !/ 000000  ' 8  #$ 2##  #5' ##'(1 2$# %D5'# 

)+,-+)(..- "+)*"

 5#  '% 36#  ' 22    # 3#% D# 3&#     55 /%3> # '>#''6#D&# 2#&#'2'  $K'#K#%2 B' 2'B##/'>' D3# # 6#82 #&#=5' #'B#>#(..,%'L#&#   2 B'    $K'#K#/  ' F 6# D3# $##  &#  $#D3#3 #  3 5#  %' J"

$# D#  #&#  =  5' #'% #  #    =  '#   &B# = 2' /

   ##'  4  &#    ' #5#  '#  '  '  2$'2 %#'  #B' ''##8'#/ %#'&# E >#6 # #3##'D3#H''&'#   '#/  #% 6#  = 3'55# '    # #  @' '$(..-%3&#   #%5 '3&' 3&'## #5# # &# &'# D' % #82 ' 3# '#%#'# 5'##2 B' ''#' 3& # 2   355  3>2 ''   4  8  3!/

   %  ' #5# #'   ##'  '2##  '   #  #6#8%3&' &# #5'24 ' #  #'(, 2$ (..-;=/ %!/ 0000003&# ;2#M#D #'/

   '   ' 'B  4  3&'# &#' ' '#  3E   /%2#=''  # #'' #'/ 5#%# '  '&>22#''%#"#' #   &= #$ '/

*/  436#  ' 22   3#5   5#    #  = '#%  '   ' '# %  (.   (@ '&2$ (..-%   #   2    '#  #  2# 6% '  # '  D3# 3  '&3# $  '>#D'6 2 8 D  ' '    $'$/   62  2#  #$> # B# N3'#2 '# >O% #N#  '6O B'24KK7 /H' %#,*1-%/,.G=,,@:%2E2D     3>2 3# 55    '&2$ (..<   ' '$ (..-% D#   # % '  ' %  ' $       #,-#, $ *

   '  '  ##2  =  D  ##' '#    % $###2 % =  D  > # '#  ''% 3   '  2# # 3# H  #  $#  #   #  >   5#   '& '&#  #5   #   '#  % 3   % '  2#3#53B'C 'C# '#/ %2# #  !/ 000000&# E  /

)+,-+)(..- "<)*"

,./  '  =  2  #$  ,- '&2$ (..-  ;    ' #5# #'   ##' # #6#%  4   '5#2%  (+ '&2$ (..-% D3#3&# &'H='&' ' 2$'2 / #&#   '  4  &  2 #' N' 2O  ,@ ' '$ (..-% #  = D'#  ##'&#  "# &' 2E2;'%##2/

,,/ / '3#,,2$(..-%!/ 000000# ' '/  #  $% ' &'   2#  # '     #  ; # 7 )@<GG)(..-" :%   4  &#  '  =    8 3#5 #'/

  436#   5#     )+,-+)(..-" % #   #   &'##5'/ &B%#&# $ $#$##6 3''  D3# # '3#52#2 '' #  #'#D3#&# $'$3 $ %=&'#'C &# 3B'C$ ;'%'$$2 & 2##/ &#  # ' ''  > &#'  ,GB..%  # &#  &    BK   =,*B../ #  ' =5# $#2'2 'L#&# #' /

  D#'# 5 # #'D## # 'B%# ##D D% '   BK #% # &#   3& C/  ;'  5# % # 3 #  '#  D3# &#    %  '  D3# &#  55 &#6=6B/  'D%#3H&# D3&'## #' B #  &>/&# M62'  '# 5# 5B# '$#6# %#8 6#'BB/  #  #& '#   #/  &#  ' 55   2#" ' '  #  #%     'B % # &#  ' = '# /  &#  5##  '2 D 3 #  = # D  5'  3'  &'#    # 3 #  E /

 $/ !/ #&#  % >  = 3!      ' %       D#  2'#/'5#2  '  # #  %##   5# D'D'#2# H "=#2 BB3''%3!'#  '2 #D2 =#3#  6/

  3 # #26#$ '&6$  D      3#/  >2 3# 2 #  3# #5#  '# ''22';' 8&2 / 38% >  &#  '&   'C%  '#    $K'#K#/  H  5#  '# &#  2# 3#'  3B'C     2 B'? H'#  ## #'D #  '3B=D$ &#  ''22/

)+,-+)(..- "-)*"

  5' #'  H3#%> '# = >26#'  #3H # '355 $  2'2 'L#'## / &# $# 38/

 /  23#%' '=5# $##  >255 3#/ &B%#2# '#'&# =  D3 > # '#  ''    ''  '2    J& % 2#'$3#  5#'###D2#/   >2&# E '5#=22$3# H 55  H5#6 '#/

 /  4   2#   ##'/   3   '' =  D3 & > #'# '5#J& /

,(/   ''  ,< 2$ (..-%  ' 6   !/ 000000'$&#' #'#286# #'' #8 3 #*.B#55,  '#   3## '#    3 # *, # (  /  3 '2 =  #  &#6  ;' 32#'2 %' ##  '#/''  %;62   &5## #5 > '# " 2/

& ( 

,/   ;   2  # &   ;## #' '2  %  '   &$7 /<- '#3'6# #';###(('&2$,*+,"  "  ( .<?  / -@ / , # /    '#   ' 2##  #&  ,( 2$,*G<" " <,.:/

(/  'D #55  55#  '   =  #  #' # #D ' =  ;##D'22%P '#  P'55#;'#2E2' 7 /1./, :/

  >''  =;##D'22%#' ;'#  2E2'/

@/ / 4'3 #+#+ %'DP '# 2#25 '#   ' =''%'# #2#=##'%D#  5#3'$; 3''#; #7 #-@#- :/

 $/ 38%!/ 0000004 2#2  (, 2$(..-% 3 '#   (12E22'#/ % #' %'#D3 '#  =  / 6#58' /

+/ /  '#  3E    '2   ##  '#  ' 3#  3'55#  &  # %   '#  '#% 3'$ #

)+,-+)(..- "1)*"

D3# '#  ' #  =  '55  &  # %   ## = 32##  #'& #'= ' 2'#3>#2'   %'D  =#5##'=7 J,((<@ '#/+/<<?,,*,@-'#/(/,@*?,,G,1'#/,/,*?,,- *+'#/@$/? )-<,)(..+(+'A (..+?I/(2$,1:/ '#   5# 2##   & 32EB     ;6  ' =  # #'  ##  & D# # '  '55 % 3#    # D3'# 32=2'#5#''##'7 J,(.$((+ '#/($/((* E # :/'# 3E  ' # ' 3'$#6 #'#  '6#5 2'H&' ?# 55# D;6# >D###  # 7 J,(,<+'#/ (/<1? )@GG),1(+;#,1:/

 $/  38%  #$ 2##  #5   55#22  #6 ' B  # #6/  2  '    '# 2    55   '&'#  '   3 #  =  '#   3#   D3# '#  #'=3 > #D''4  ##'# #6#/ #$'62 = 2# #    ' %  # H  2#% '   '2 #' '% &'# ''22   5#  DD B &  ' #  #'   62/

</  3 # @.  3'' 6  32##'  '    &B#=# #'' #8(1' '$,*1-7 "41+,/<,:   &#6 8  , ;&# (..<% &'#  D  2# 38& '  '  2#  '#   E   # = #  & #5 'D3# ># ' #>D =3 # ='#3# / #  2#  '# = #  & #5 ' #   ##' ##    ' #& # # / 8'&#'#7 J,(( @<*'#/, (:/

   38% #    $# D !/ 000000  #  ' 3#5  $ ### ''#  #',+;# (..-/'D % 6 > '     '  =   6%  4  #'#  32  55#  ' ''   #   ' 2#  '# = #  & #5 ' # 23'$#6 #''#'2 = > #/

  3 '# ##5# 6''&'#3# #'D#B= ' # #D/ 'D%##''5#2/

-/   '   'D  ; /  #   3#  # #6%  2'2 2#=B6!/ 000000%#"## $5# 3# ;###/

)+,-+)(..- "G)*"

+  &(  &    

,-.#/

&$'# ; @' '$ *'&2$(..-!'# 0000003 '#; # 3  ' ##'&#  '2'$#     &#6 #'  (1  2$ (..- #  #  ' 2#  '#= # & #5%''$  '?

01-2-$!/

'';' #''Q )@<GG)(..- Q )+,-+)(..-' Q )+,-+)(..-?

.#$/

; ?

# D3#3 M32'2 ?

#  D% '5'22  >  # G(   #&    '# 5   #$ 5  ,1 ;# (..< 7 J"4 ,1@/,,.:%    E    E  '      ;' D# #&   ' #5# #' "&   #$ 5%   &'#  '2 #8'# $#?22'#''# ##D'#'% 2' #5 2'H& ' #6 ' ''2 #?# '#  E    #$ 5% ,...  ,+%  &'# '  '  &'#  '#D > '# #'  3 # +(  J/    E     #8  '#'  ' % #&'D '22 2'H  &% '#&  E  ;'#  = 3&'#?

'22#D E =!"#$%&' ' %##D3 &# '2'$# &#6 #' =3'55#5' =/

)+,-+)(..- "*)*"

4#6 9 !2'&H%# %!!/HB8  B#%;6/

'2 #$2##  #59

655#8";# ;//#/9  &#"# 9     / /'&H   

'#'5'2 E  '22#D> #/

 8&%  655#89           

)+,-+)(..-