Court dismissed appeal for violating party autonomy and defense rights by raising issues ex officio.
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertThe Court of Cassation dismissed the appeal because the lower court raised a dispute ex officio that the parties had explicitly excluded. The parties argued that the lower court violated the principle of party disposition and their right to defense by introducing a contested issue not raised by them. The court ruled that judges cannot initiate disputes contrary to public order when the parties have clearly excluded their existence.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generiertCode Judiciaire - 1138, al. 2: A judge violates the principle of party disposition and the right of defense by ex officio raising a dispute excluded by the parties.
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertZitierte Rechtsprechung
KI-generiertVolltext
Fiches 1 - 2 Méconnaît le principe dispositif et le principe général du droit imposant le respect des droits de la défense, le juge qui élève d'office une contestation, étrangère à l'ordre public, dont les parties avaient exclu l'existence (1). Thésaurus Cassation: DROITS DE LA DEFENSE - MATIERE CIVILE Mots libres: DROITS DE LA DEFENSE. - MATIERE CIVILE. - Principe dispositif. - Violation.
- Art. 1138, al. 2, Cjud. Bases légales: Code Judiciaire - 1138,L2 Thésaurus Cassation: TRIBUNAUX - MATIERE CIVILE - Généralités Mots libres: TRIBUNAUX. - MATIERE CIVILE. - Généralités. - Droits de la défense.
- Principe dispositif. - Violation. - Art. 1138, al. 2, Cjud. Note:
(1) Cass., 17 septembre 1999, R.G. n° C.98.0144.F ECLI:BE:CASS:1999:ARR.19990917.4 , n° 467.
Annotations Publications: ARRESTEN VAN HET HOF VAN CASSATIE - - 2000(657) PASICRISIE BELGE
- - 2000(I/657)